While other items from the HiP line are good this is one that wasn't the greatest. It constantly broke which required more sharpening which wasted product. I've tried using it at room temp, it was too soft. I put it in the 'fridge to harden up a bit and it was too crumbly. Instead of an eyeliner I use it as a black eyeshadow base by using the broken bits on my eyelid instead. Not worth the money and I don't recommend it. The color is great but the product overall isn't.