Wonderful Colour Payoff and Staying Power
I have two of these lipsticks in the shades Cheerful Cherry and Beautiful Berry (the latter of which is not listed on this site). I love both of them. The pigmentation is wonderful, they glide on smoothly, and they last quite a while before I feel like I need to reapply. The packaging is wonderful and you couldn't tell that it's a cheap product just by looking at it. The only problem I've ever had is that the mechanism that turns the bullet is slightly loose or something with my Beautiful Berry stick, because sometimes it won't turn up or (more problematically) won't turn down. But it's worth the price.
The shade in the picture is Beautiful Berry.
Favorite. Lipstick. Ever.
If you're looking for an amazing lipstick that moisturizes and stays all day, then stop. You've found it.
Seriously though. I can't get enough of these. They are so insanely creamy and pigmented, but at the same time they're not at that level of creamy where they settle into lines and make you look like a hot mess.
They do a nice job at moisturizing your lips, and the staying power is phenomenal. (I'm even a smoker and they last all day on me.)
The packaging is so cute and sleek, you would never guess these cost a mere five bucks. (Less than that when ELF is having one of their million sales.)
Overall, my heart belongs to these lipsticks. No lie.
Okay so heres the thing, the color swatches online dont look how they do in real life... but to me I think the colors I have look nicer and I love them. I use them all the time. They don't dry out my lips and they have great color pay off. The only thing that might bother people are the smell, but that doesn't both me at all. I cant wait to get more.
I wish I could send it in a time machine to my high school self
I remember how much I searched for the perfect, inexpensive nude lipstick...I mean really nude lipstick. It seemed like I'd always end up with shades that are too shimmery, too pink, too dry, etc.
This lipstick would have been absolutely perfect. The Natural Nymph shade is very light in tone, none-shimmery, not dry, nothing crazy...just perfectly nude. And if doesn't show any sign of being cheap, except for the price! Would pair great with a smoky eye.
The only reason I'm not giving it five stars is because, though it's a great lipstick, I'm mostly gushing over the shade, which is objective.
I wish I bought another color...
...but I bought this online on their website, so I didn't know that the swatches weren't true to color. Its more coral than I thought it would be, so this ended up sitting in my train case. BUT it does glide on nicely, and has staying power for a lipstick that cost under five dollars. I don't heart this lipstick, but I don't hate it either. I think I would like it better if I had a different shade.
Nicely pigmented and very hydrating
These lipsticks are really great. There is a nice variety of colours. The pigmentation is good and it feels good on the lips.
Packaging is nice, but if you have more than one shade of these it can be har to tell them apart without opening them.
Really great for the price.
Creamy, Long-Lasting Nude Brown Color, Maybe Too Neutral, Flimsy Packaging
Probably one of e.l.f's more impressive products, their Mineral Lipsticks are surprisingly creamy and glide on application especially compared to their Essentials Lipsticks, which are dry and drag over the lips. The pigmentation appears standard for a drugstore lipstick, maybe two coats will bring out its true color.
The packaging is elegantly minimalist for a drugstore lipstick as well. Though it looks great, the quality of their lipstick packaging seems to vary, as I have another one of these lipsticks in Cool Coral that has a sturdier lipstick case than my Bare Brown lipstick, of which the bullet casing is audibly loose if shaken. The closing mechanism also feels too loose. I worry about taking the Bare Brown lipstick with me as I am afraid of the packaging will fall apart in my bag.
As for the color Bare Brown, I enjoy that it is a neutral everyday shade that works out great for medium skin tones. For those who have hyper-pigmented lips, Bare Brown can neutralize the pigmentation and soften the look of your lips. However, for those whose lips don't have much pigmentation to begin with, Bare Brown may be so neutral brown that it makes your lips look lifeless. I compared it to Maybelline's Color Sensational Lipstick in Totally Toffee, which is a slightly drier, less creamier formula than e.l.f.'s Mineral Lipsticks. The two colors are very similar, except that I find that I like Maybelline's Totally Toffee over e.l.f's Bare Brown due to the Totally Toffee having a hint of warmth in it; it appears much more natural and less made-up.
But to reiterate, I do recommend this shade of e.l.f.'s Mineral Lipsticks for lips that are highly pigmented and need to be more neutralized. Because the formula is also creamy and long-wearing, I also highly recommend this lipstick for those with dry lips such as myself.
I have this in the color "Nicely Nude" Yet another AMAZING e.l.f lipstick! The color is very matte but not dry look at all. I really love the smoothness and non sticky feel of this lipstick. Needless to say, I bought 4 more! It nourishes and soothes my lips. The lasting power- Eh. I had to re apply often, but i didnt mind re applying ;) i love this!
soft matte baby pink
I love this! I know some people said it wasn't what they expected from the site's image, but I googled it first and it was exactly what I was looking for. I use UD lip primer underneath it, and it dries perfectly matte on me. Not a very good 'nude' for my skin tone, but a nice (pale) baby pink.
Perfect Dark Nude Color for WOC!
I have been on the hunt for a really nice, nude color that brings out the brown in my skin and this lipstick definitely does the trick! It is a brown with slight red/orange undertones, but nothing too noticeable. I have had my eye on Bare Brown for a while and finally decided to get it last month. It glides on smoothly and I can't believe I'm saying this, but almost as smoothly as the NYX round lipsticks in my opinion. I think that the "mineral" aspect of this lipstick makes it glide on as smooth as it does, especially compared to the essential lipstick line by e.l.f. I think you get a nice range of color options. When I saw the packaging for this I died because it was so AMAZING. It's so sleek and black and the best packaging by e.l.f! The price is $6 which is expensive for e.l.f, but I think it's totally worth it!
Pros: -Price -Texture -Packaging
Cons: -Availability (only online)