Good pencil eyeliners?

9

Sort By

Oct 25, 2014

Lindsay H.

^

Oct 25, 2014

Kira S.

NYX waterproof eye crayons.

Oct 25, 2014

Victoria P.

Urban decay 24/7.

Oct 25, 2014

Shiro M.

Rimmel Scandaleyes kohl liner or Revlon colorstay.

Oct 26, 2014

Katherine L.

Maybelline Unstoppable is my holy grail :)

Oct 26, 2014

Alicia C.

Rimmel Scandal eyes :)

Oct 26, 2014

Hannah K.

There are quite a few that I consider to be absolutely wonderful:

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-on Eye Pencils-they're fabulous. they come in a ridiculously wide range of colors, they have magical staying power and they actually set into place after about 15 seconds, so that they're impossible to move.

Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Crayons-these are beautiful. they stay put on the waterline like nothing else, they have a nice shade range (about 10 or so shades) and they are incredibly easy to apply.

Too Faced eyeliner pencils-These also have a few nice colors, they're basically indelible and they are extremely richly pigmented.

Smashbox Self-sharpening eyeliner-the shade range is getting better, but honestly they're wonderful. They stay put, and they stay sharp which allows for a very straight line every time.

Make Up For Ever-I wore this in the pool once, and nothing happened. They have a ridiculous amount of colors, a beautiful formula, and a really smooth application.

I'm sure I can think of more, but those are a good start

Oct 26, 2014

Cat C.

I agree with the Marc Jacobs and MUFE liners. I've never seen these fail anyone before! They are incredibly rich and creamy and stay put.

Oct 26, 2014

Hannah K.

Ooh, Cat, have you seen the new Marc Jacobs colors?? They're BEAUTIFUL.

Oct 26, 2014

Cat C.

Yes! I saw that they have a holiday set with some gorgeous colors, too!

Oct 26, 2014

Isabel M.

Rimmel scandal eyes kohl eyeliner in black and nude! Those are my go Tos!