What's a GOOD long lasting pencil eyeliner? Help Please.
20
Sort By
- Free & easy returns on all orders.
- Ship To: | EN
-
Contact Us
Our customer service team in the US is ready to assist you.
1-877-992-5474 Available Now
Monday - Friday
7 AM – 4 PM PTSaturday
7 AM – 4 PM PT
- Login
- Join
- Your Bag 0
Aug 24, 2011
Soozee S.
So recently my eye developed some irritation to all liquid liners. Pencil does nothing so I'm looking to invest in a long lasting one. Something thats smooth and good quality. I was thinking Urban decay 24/7? Idk. Any products in mind?
Aug 24, 2011
Tree M.
I love that one! Do gel eyeliners irritate your eyes? Because my absolute favorite eyeliner is MAC's fluidlines! (:
Aug 24, 2011
Olivia G.
The smashbox liners are absolutely amazing! They're waterproof and have a sharpener in the cap. They're $19 but worth it since otherwise you'd just be running through liners. They stay in your waterline soo much longer than anything else I've ever tried
Aug 24, 2011
Victoria F.
If you want a good drugstore pencil then Liquiline by Covergirl is pretty awesome(of course its not gonna be as good as UD 24/7, but I know I sure can't afford one D: )
Aug 24, 2011
Courtney A.
urban decay 24/7 or make up for ever aqua eyes! they may as well be the same thing lol
Aug 24, 2011
Soma S.
^I second MUFE Aqua Eyes... their entire Aqua line is so waterproof, it's amost a pain to take off without the right makeup remover. You can run through a carwash and it would still stay put!
Aug 24, 2011
Ida H.
I love the Stila smudgestick in stingray!
Aug 25, 2011
Soozee S.
Thanks for all the suggestions guys! :) Now I gotta figure out which one to pick. Lol
Aug 25, 2011
Christina H.
stilla for more expensive route but for drugstore brand i would say revolon color stay
Aug 25, 2011
Alexis B.
Rimmel exaggerate waterproof eye definer!! You can get it at walgreens I know.. not too sure about CVS or walmart.
Aug 25, 2011
Amanda L.
Urban Decay's 24/7 does NOT work for me, it may go on smooth but it does not last, it fades and smudges even if I use a primer. I perfer Revlon Colorstay much more, also Wet n Wild Cream liner is pretty good only $2.99.
Aug 27, 2011
Kaitlyn G.
Personally a stick liner has always creased for me. Have you ever tried a cream liner that you apply with a brush? I switched to that and i like using a brush to put it on because i have more control on the line/shape i want to make.
Also, you should try a felt tip eyeliner, i can't quite remember the brand but they have them at any drugstore and they're just like a marker.
If you find a good stick liner such as UD 24/7 and you have issues with creasing you can then apply a good black eyeshadow over your eyeliner and then use a setting spray.
Aug 27, 2011
Alexis C.
Milani Liquif'eye Liner in Black. 5-7 dollars. Dark, creamy, long lasting. I love it.
Aug 28, 2011
Sarah-Louise H.
i like BarryM eyeliner... Its so creamy and stays on all day without smudging... But you can only get that if your in the uk
urban decay 47// is great aswell...Or anebelle smudge liner
Aug 29, 2011
Shelly T.
Prestige Total Intensity. IMO, much better staying power than UD 24/7 and with better pigmentation, not to mention the Prestige ones cost about 1/3 as much.
Aug 29, 2011
Jewel A.
Now a couple of amazing liners I have come across are....Maybelline Eye Studio cream liner pot, Stila's stay all day felt tip liner, or if you are really into liners there are alot of fun colors by Makeup forever that you can literally go swimming in that will not come off and they are the AQUA EYES LINERS.I swear by them!!! With all the great options you've been given you are sure to find a FAV!!!
Aug 30, 2011
Samantha G.
ive been hearing really good things about the new nyx slide-on pencils
Aug 31, 2011
Nadia B.
My first question to you is, do you have watery eyes? I have that issue and it's been a struggle to find a pencil liner that works great. Have you tried a waterproof gel liner? They go on just like liquid, but without the irritation. Loreal HIP has a great gel liner pot. If you have your heart set on a pencil, try the Urban Decay 24/7 pencil. There is something I've noticed when it comes to any pencil. Black usually does not hold up all day unless you smudge a matching black eyeshadow over the pencil to set it. Colored pencils for whatever reason last the best for me. I love Milani's automatic pencils. They come in a array of colors and they last all day. Good luck!