Good drug store eyeliners I still have not come across, unfortunately, but I am very familiar with the bad ones. Wet n Wild Mega Last is simply awful. It's like trying to get a pen with no ink to work! Maybelline Define-A-Line has very rich color but doesn't stay on more than 20 minutes without smudging. Surprisingly, it works extremely well blended onto your eyelids as a matte eyeshadow.
Not even joking the maybelline master drama eye liner pencil beats all of my other liners, including tarte, clinique, urban decay and everything else:P
The black is called midnight master, but I have the brown and a silver as well and they are glorious:P
I LOVE the Maybelline Line Stiletto! It's a felt tip liquid liner that is super easy to apply. And I also love the Maybelline Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner! Super pigmented and smooth. :D I hope that helps!
The maybelline master drama eyeliner is awesome! I have it in sapphire strength which is a gorgeous blue color and is great when you want to add a little pop to your eyes 😃
My favorite for 5 years straight is Maybelline Line Stiletto. It's easy to apply precise line because it has a flexible felt nib applicator, and the formula sets pretty quickly. Not only that, but it has amazing staying power against smudging for a washable eyeliner, unless you deliberately tried to take it off.
If you want a good waterproof drugstore eyeliner, Maybelline's Unstoppable Eyeliner is also good.
I agree with Bria J. !!! the Milani Liquif'eye eyeliner has to the BEST liquid eyeliner!! Lasts alot longer than any other liquid eyeliners ive tried!!!
For creme/gel I recommend e.l.f.'s Studio Cream Eyeliner. It's super creamy, lightweight, pigmented and long-wearing, and it really is so fluid that application is a breeze. For liquid, I recommend NYC New York Color's High Definition Liquid Eyeliner - it's a fine point felt-tip marker, so it's incredibly easy to use, it's richly pigmented and it wears all day and night without transferring or fading.
Beautylish is a diverse and positive community that is ever-evolving. While tastes may be personal, please be respectful in your conversation and withhold judgement or criticism. We're all here to learn and grow.
Contribute Thoughtfully
We encourage you to participate in all conversations, but try to use proper spelling, grammar and capitalization. Your two cents will be taken more seriously if you take the time to present it well.
Stay Relevant and Avoid Self-Promotion
When replying, feel free to link to a blog or video that contains an answer to that thread. Please don't ask people to check your site or act in a self-promotional way out of context. You don’t need to end posts with your blog, YouTube, Facebook, or Twitter—they are displayed in your signature card.
Please don't post contests, giveaways, swaps or exchanges on Beautylish.
Be Yourself
The most rewarding conversations are genuine and authentic with real people. Please don’t use forums to post commercial messages for direct selling purposes or on behalf of a company or commercial enterprise.
Let Us Know
Beautylish doesn’t allow hateful or disrespectful comments. If you see something that seems inappropriate or wrong, please send us a note at help@beautylish.com.
Follow Us
Get the Beautylish Newsletter to hear about exclusive events, new products,
expert tips and more!
Jul 07, 2012
McJane Y.
Just looking for some new eyeliners to try out. HELPP! :)
Jul 07, 2012
Toshira A.
E.L.F.'s cream eyeliner is amazing. It's $3 from target.
Jul 07, 2012
Jessica C.
Maybelline Hyper Sharp Liner:)
Jul 07, 2012
Princess J.
Good drug store eyeliners I still have not come across, unfortunately, but I am very familiar with the bad ones. Wet n Wild Mega Last is simply awful. It's like trying to get a pen with no ink to work! Maybelline Define-A-Line has very rich color but doesn't stay on more than 20 minutes without smudging. Surprisingly, it works extremely well blended onto your eyelids as a matte eyeshadow.
Jul 07, 2012
DimePieceOnaDime D.
wet n' wild cream liner, is LOVELY!! love love love it
Jul 07, 2012
Terra M.
Not even joking the maybelline master drama eye liner pencil beats all of my other liners, including tarte, clinique, urban decay and everything else:P
The black is called midnight master, but I have the brown and a silver as well and they are glorious:P
Jul 07, 2012
Monica M.
I LOVE the Maybelline Line Stiletto! It's a felt tip liquid liner that is super easy to apply. And I also love the Maybelline Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner! Super pigmented and smooth. :D I hope that helps!
Jul 07, 2012
bangalore b.
As of now I'm loving the Maybelline drama studio gel eyeliner.. I have the black one.. Almost a year since I have been using it
Jul 07, 2012
Havoc M.
Maybelline eye studio gel liner makes me happy. I like it better than my MAC gel liners.
Jul 07, 2012
Allie M.
The maybelline master drama eyeliner is awesome! I have it in sapphire strength which is a gorgeous blue color and is great when you want to add a little pop to your eyes 😃
Jul 07, 2012
Terra M.
I can only ever find the maybelline gel liner in brown...It seems like I definitely need to pick up the black.
Jul 07, 2012
Michelle A.
Loving elf cream eyeliner!!
Jul 07, 2012
Sojourner W.
Loreal Linuer Intense Eyeliner in Black is my favorite! The InColor Fabuliner is a nice felt tip pen too.
Jul 07, 2012
Bria J.
Milani Liquif'eye Eyeliner
Jul 07, 2012
Savannah D.
Maybelline eyeliners are amazing!(:
Jul 07, 2012
Mary Anne M.
My favorite for 5 years straight is Maybelline Line Stiletto. It's easy to apply precise line because it has a flexible felt nib applicator, and the formula sets pretty quickly. Not only that, but it has amazing staying power against smudging for a washable eyeliner, unless you deliberately tried to take it off.
If you want a good waterproof drugstore eyeliner, Maybelline's Unstoppable Eyeliner is also good.
Jul 07, 2012
Manuela B.
I agree with Bria J. !!! the Milani Liquif'eye eyeliner has to the BEST liquid eyeliner!! Lasts alot longer than any other liquid eyeliners ive tried!!!
Jul 08, 2012
Kristen A.
For creme/gel I recommend e.l.f.'s Studio Cream Eyeliner. It's super creamy, lightweight, pigmented and long-wearing, and it really is so fluid that application is a breeze. For liquid, I recommend NYC New York Color's High Definition Liquid Eyeliner - it's a fine point felt-tip marker, so it's incredibly easy to use, it's richly pigmented and it wears all day and night without transferring or fading.
Jul 08, 2012
Pamela W.
Wet N' Wild gel eyeliner and Milani Liquif'eye Eyeliner
Jul 08, 2012
Kendall B.
I really like the Almay one
Jul 08, 2012
Lacey A.
ELF cream liner or Maybelline line stilletto
Jul 09, 2012
Lili H.
Milani glitter black eyeliner. It stays on all day for me AND they don't TEST ON ANIMALS :D
Jul 10, 2012
Priya C.
Sleeks eyeliner. The one that looks like lipstick. Kohl
Jul 10, 2012
Emilie N.
maybelline master precise by eye studio!(:
Jul 10, 2012
Tania P.
MILANI LIQUIF-EYE PENCILS! omg i LOVE them :)