What's a Good Under Eye Concealer?

29
Sort By

Apr 16, 2012

Rebecca T.

fit me concealer leaves me looking ashy, elf concealer doesn't conceal very well, MAC seems too cakey. HELP! (i have dark circles that seem to sink in, not puff out)

what works for you guys

Apr 16, 2012

Emily V.

Mac select moisturecover it isn't in a pot it is in a tube and it is quite liquidy and works great

Apr 16, 2012

Rebecca T.

Thanx, I check that out! 

Apr 16, 2012

Alexa D.

I use from lancome and i apsolutely love it

Apr 16, 2012

Santina A.

I really like the MAC Select Cover Up.. it's in a squeeze tube, not the Select Moisturecover that is in a tube with a doe foot applicator. I use the tiniest bit under my eyes, followed by the Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Dark Circle Eraser in the shade 160 Brightener. It's irridescent and pink but adds the most sheer glow under my eyes. I have a lot of friends that love the Dark Circle Eraser in their regular shade for under eyes, because it doesn't crease! You should definitely check it out - I got mine on sale for $6!  

Mac Pro Longwear or Kevyn Aucoin SSE

Apr 16, 2012

Eninna S.

Erase paste from benefit or Garneir roll on dark circle eraser. Both are really good. 

I use Boi-ing by Benefit, love it!

Apr 28, 2012

Samantha G.

maybelline's instant age rewind dark circle corrector. it's moisturizing and never creases- i don't need to set it with a powder and it lasts all day.

Apr 28, 2012

Amanda C.

I use Revlon Colorstay Concealer and Hard Candy's Glamoflauge 

Apr 29, 2012

Angela C.

Amazing Cosmetics makes a good one (Amazing Concealer) that gives great coverage - it starts out pretty thin, then thickens as you work it and blends out beautifully. I also like the YSL Touche Eclat ("8 hours of sleep in a tube!" they call it) as it brightens and conceals, though it is a little thin for some days. It's also pricey, but Milani makes a great dupe, called HD Advance Concealer, which I've found to be just as good, though it comes in fewer colors :(

Amazing Concealer: $28
Touche Eclat: $40
HD Advance Concealer: Less than $8 

I use the Garnier Dark circle eraser but my dark circles aren't too bad. I know that Erase Paste works great! My mom uses it lol I would try that! 

Apr 29, 2012

Bee K.

Erase Paste was my "under eye saver"! The salmon colored concealer is what you should go for and theirs is amazing. ONE container lasted me over a year so it is definitely worth the price. I also used it on my other scars that I had and it works wonders to help brighten you up and it lasts. Definitely the best I've used and I've got genetically dark under eye circles :/

Isabella H.

Apr 29, 2012

Isabella H.

benefit's erase paste is really great to brighten your undereye circles while benefit's boing concealer helps to cover up the "purple-ness" of your dark circles! love both

Apr 30, 2012

Alyson T.

^^^^Yesssss^^^ I Love the LA Girl Pro Concealer. I also use Ruby Kisses face creator. I love it. Its super inexpensive (around 5 bucks) and you get a lot of product!!!

Apr 30, 2012

Fancie B.

Aww I'm sorry to hear the Fit Me concealer didn't work for you! I just really got into under eye concealing and it works ok for me I suppose. I do really like NYX's concealer in a jar though! You should give that a try! You should try out the LA Girl HD concealer too like Sojourner and Alyson suggested. I've never tried it but I've heard it works miracles. I've been looking for it in stores everywhere

Apr 30, 2012

Shelly T.

Bobbi Brown Corrector. If MAC didn't just discontinue their Studio Sculpt Concealer recently, I'd recommend that as well.

Apr 30, 2012

Cassidy G.

Eve Pearl salmon concealer! 

May 01, 2012

Kristalyn G.

I had really dark under eye circles and I had tried a lot of different brands to cover them but I finally asked for help at the MAC counter and the makeup artist helped me pick out the right shade for my circles (Studio fix concealer, the one in the pot) it goes on creamy so for me it isn't too cakey. If you aren't sure of what you need for yourself I would just suggest you ask either at Sephora or MAC or at a department store counter for help with concealers and they Makeup Artists are usually always willing to help you out. Your skin may be different from me or any other person on this forum so you need to see what works best for you. 

May 01, 2012

Marcela F.

1.Tartes Under eye concealers
2. Clinique All About Eyes Concealer in 03 Light Petal (peachy tone).
2. Maybelline Instant age rewind concealer

May 01, 2012

Gabbi D.

Bobbi Brown's corrector is my favorite!

May 01, 2012

Davia R.

i mostly use mac concealer 

May 02, 2012

Maribel D.

Kat Von D tattoo concealer Love it :)

May 02, 2012

Theresa S.

Though I use Mac once the most often, I currently like to use the La Roche Posay under the eye concealer. It comes in a yellow tone so it kind of erases them.
I really works if you have kind of blue circles under your eye!  

May 02, 2012

Consuelo A.

i like Avons "MagiX eye illuminator". It slight and its not expensive

Add a Reply