May 19, 2012
Hey guys! i am in need of a drugstore eyeliner that will stay on my waterline!! i hate pencils you have to sharpen though! any suggestions?
elf makeup eyeliners are great u can get them at target hard candy at walmart is good too
I absolutely love this covergirl one its not exactly a pencil. Its more of a crayon that you can twist up instead of sharpen & it glides on pretty smooth.
Rimmel have great eyeliners, I've also heard a lot of good things about the Maybelline gel liner :)
I love the Revlon Colorstay eyeliner! Very long lasting.
May 22, 2012
I also have the Maybelline gel liner and I seriously love it. It's super black. And of course they have other colors. To me, It's better than Mac's Blacktrack Fluidline.
Whatever eyeliner you get, try lighting it with a lighter before applying. It not only makes it stay on your eyes all day without smudging, but it also makes it look more dramatic & darker. :]
Prestige Total Intensity. It is a pencil eyeliner, yes, but -- IMO -- it's fantastic.
Or, to steer you away from the drugstore, splurge a little bit and go for Inglot's gel eyeliner. It dries quickly, to my understanding, so would work very well on the waterline.
Loreal HIP Black pencil not kohl
Im enjoying my Essence gel eyeliner it stays put i actually slept with my makeup on I KNOW bad bad..but it was still on my water line! LOL so for 1.99 can't beat it!
May 24, 2012
I love the Essence gel linet available at Ulta for only $3.50. Super creamy and smooth. Also love Rimmel Soft kohl pencils and Maybeline gel liner.
May 25, 2012
I love jordana fabliner 2.99 at walgreens totally awesome felt tip pen
L'oreal's eye kohl in carbon black. Its a fat pencil and comes with a sharpener but its suuuper black like MACs smolder kohl eyeliner. I LOVe it.
The milani liquifeye is pretty amazing. (i think its spelled like that)
May 26, 2012
I agree with Latoya C., the Milani Liquify (spell check) pencils are really good!
May 27, 2012
Since you don't like pencils you should really try elf's cream liners
May 28, 2012
Milani liquifeye. You have to sharpen it, but it is super easy to sharpen and it's the creamiest, richest black you're going to find at a drugstore.
Maybelline works perfect for me.
I find that using a gel liner works best. Just take any pencik and dip the tip and run it in the waterline.
Jun 06, 2012
Maybelline eyestudio gel eyeliner in blackest black! its suppose to last 12 hours! its also waterproof!
Wet n Wild gel eyeliner.
I love love LOVE Maybelline's Master Drama eyeliner! It's a twist up eyeliner.
Comments and topics that do not comply with these rules will be removed by Beautylish Staff.
Repeat offenders may be banned.
Beautylish is a diverse, positive and respectful community. It’s okay to disagree with someone, but be constructive and don’t be rude.
We have a zero tolerance policy toward rude comments, negativity and harassment.
Make posts easy to understand by using proper spelling, grammar and capitalization. Post topics in the correct category and do not make duplicate posts.
Duplicate, miscategorized, and difficult to understand posts will be deleted by Beautylish Staff.
Avoid self-promotion or commercial messages. Don’t post other people’s work and claim it as your own.
Contests, giveaways, swaps and exchanges are not allowed on Beautylish.
Use the flag button to report inappropriate or disrespectful behavior,
or email us at firstname.lastname@example.org.