SugarPill Heartbreak Palette

May 31, 2012

Heather H.

You're better off buying it, in my opinion, because you'll probably spend the same amount or more on similar colours, it's pretty affordable at 4 - 1.25" pan eyeshadows for $34.

But if you don't want to buy the palette, here is a great blog post comparing different eyeshadows: http://www.phyrra.net/2012/05/sugarpill-heart-breaker-palette-swatches-and-thoughts.html

Jun 1, 2012

Soma S.

^def. agree w/ Heather on this one... Ms. Shrinkle outdid herself by providing us with such awesome palettes, and even though brights are something I never wear, I'm proud to have both palettes in my collection for an accent color when needed. =]

Jun 1, 2012

Yasmin K.

If you're going to dupe it dupe it with LESS EXPENSIVE products. For example, the MUFE 159 mentioned costs $20 for 0.08 oz. Velocity on it's own costs $12 for 0.14 oz. - almost TWICE the amount of product for $8 less! So which is the better deal? Sugarpill's palette for $34 since you get four shadows that are each 0.14 oz.

Jun 1, 2012

Yasmin K.

It would still be $1 more for almost half the size of Sugarpill.

Jun 1, 2012

Yasmin K.

I don't have an issue, I'm merely pointing out it's more expensive in terms of price and that you get LESS product. You stated above, "You can buy MUFE pans for $13" but why would someone pay more money for less product if they're already looking to buy Sugarpill? That's why I posted Sugarpill is still less money for more product.

I'm not here trying to be mean or argue with you I merely pointed out, economically speaking, MUFE is more expensive either as a pan ($13 for 0.08 oz) or in a container ($20 for 0.08 oz) while Sugarpill is $12 per color and you get almost twice the amount of product (0.14 oz).

For arguement's sake let's say that MUFE has four identical shades to Sugarpill's Heartbreaker. You wrote that the pans are $13 (in the pots it's $20).

MUFE: $13 x 4 = $52 - each pan is only 0.08 oz
Sugarpill's Heartbreaker palette: $34 - each pan is 0.14 oz
Price difference: $18 for 0.24 oz less product.

If a person were to buy the MUFE in the containers it's $20 each compared to Sugarpill's $12 for each individual shadow.

MUFE: $20 x 4 = $80
Sugarpill: $12 x 4 = $48
Heartbreaker palette: $34
Price difference: $32 to $46.

Sugarpill makes a great dupe for MUFE 159 since it's less expensive and you get more product but it makes no sense to go out an BUY MUFE 159 to dupe Sugarpill's Velocity when Sugarpill is less money for more product.

Now as you pointed out in your comment above, if a person already HAS MUFE 159 but not Sugarpill's Velocity then sure they can possibly dupe it and save their money that way.

Jun 1, 2012

Rai C.

In my opinion it makes more sense to just buy the actual palette rather than go buy individual dupes for the palette. 

Jun 9, 2012

Victoria D.

Personally I love the palette. I'd just buy it! You won't be sorry!