They're Real or Roller Lash.

20

Sort By

Apr 25, 2015

Becka M.

I can't decide which one and I've never tried either and since they're the same price, I can't decide which one I want! So what would y'all recommend, Benifit They're Real or Roller Lash?

Apr 25, 2015

Rashi P.

Idk about roller lash but they're real didn't really live upto my expectations after all the great things that I had heard about it.

Apr 25, 2015

Shanae J.

They're both overrated. I'd say they're real though.

Apr 25, 2015

Traci P.

I have only tried They're Real, and I hated it with a passion lol. The formula was way too wet for me and it made my lashes a clumpy mess every time. So I would say go for Roller lash.

Apr 25, 2015

Julie F.

I have short straight lashes, I have loved they're real... But love roller lash even more. Here are my current eyes with two coats of roller lash. Only used an eyelash curler before applying mascara, not after. I enjoyed them both but I'd have to say rollerlash- mainly because it holds my shape all day.

Apr 25, 2015

J L.

I've tried a couple of benefits mascaras (including they're real but not roller lash) and they have all disappointed me. They're real is not worth the hype. It clumps, doesn't hold a curl and I feel like I'm going to poke my eye out with the wand lol

Apr 25, 2015

Jasmine S.

It all depends on your eyelashes but I personally love they're real. I have short curled lashes, if that helps.

Apr 25, 2015

Katherine L.

Personally I hate they're real! it is way too wet and doesn't hold a curl, like the ladies said.

Apr 25, 2015

Vanessa F.

I love Roller Lash! I always get compliments on my eye lashes when I wear it.
I have pretty long lashes already if that helps any. :)

Apr 25, 2015

Rebecca J.

Roller lash is great I love it. It's the best mascara I've used in a while. No clumpy lashes at all and gives length and it holds a curl well but you would still need to use an eyelash curler. I love they're real too but its such a nightmare to take off however it gives me dramatic lashes. I would pick roller lash though :)

Apr 25, 2015

Ashlee C.

I have both and I like They're Real better. I've never noticed a difference in mascara until I had tried if. Roller lash doesn't do much of anything in my opinion.

Apr 25, 2015

Brianna M.

I've tried both, I hated the they're real for the same reason as the ladies above it is too wet and it clumps I would always get mascara all over my lids. I honestly really liked the roller lash because I didnt curk my lashes before or after but I felt like this mascara actually gave them a curl and it didnt clump them either so I would definitely say the roller lash.

Apr 25, 2015

Bella L.

I love rolelr lash I recently got a sample size and love it

Apr 26, 2015

Regina B.

I have never tried Roller Lash, but I have wanted to. I did try They're Real, and honestly I loved the way my lashes looked. But it is so difficult to remove. I used the They're Real makeup remover and still had a hard time getting it off. I stopped using it because I was losing lashes at the end of the day.

Apr 26, 2015

Reese S.

I personally am a benefit enthusiast 😂 but they're real DID NOT do it for me and I've got insanely long lashes and it didn't lengthen or volumize them whatsoever. The roller lash, on the other hand, is exceptional. It's my go to mascara and ever since I started using it I've gotten nothing but compliments on my lashes! I highly recommend it!

Apr 26, 2015

Reese S.

The roller lash gave my lashes a beautiful natural "lift" and was black and separated my lashes. I truly love it.

Apr 26, 2015

Makeup A.

Ugh I am not a fan of benefit. I bought the roller for my mom because she has very short lashes and I felt is was built for that. They're real was ok for me but I much prefer others. The brush was the major downfall

Apr 26, 2015

Thea S.

I like both of them. I'd say they're real for length, roller lash for curl and volume.

Apr 26, 2015

Kendra H.

They are both highly overrated to me. However, if you have your heart set on one, I'd go with they're real.

Apr 26, 2015

Kimberly C.

Roller lash is meant to be used with They're real.

Apr 27, 2015

Allison W.

I liked they're real and I also like roller lash... Haven't tried them together though. This is two coats of roller lash but I did curl my lashes first...

Apr 30, 2015

Kyla K.

I have only tried they're real and honestly it isn't fabulous. At first it was pretty good but it dried out fast. Personally I would recommend perversion by urban decay or better than sex (weird names I know! But together they work well too!)