Which is better the 1st Nude pallet or the chocolate bar pallet.

12

Sort By

Jul 31, 2015

Hannah S.

So my 16th is coming up and I have to choose between the nude pallet or the chocolate bar pallet and I'm torn between the two.šŸ˜”I don't really use dark eyeshadow's, I don't like the dark smokey eye kind of look so I don't really use blacks. I love the half baked and naked colour in the nude pallet and I love the salted caramel and marzipan colours in the chocolate bar pallet. So this is really tearing me apart and I just would like to know which is the better one to get and why.
Thanks for the help ā¤ļøxxx

Jul 31, 2015

Robin M.

We are literally in the same position! I turn 16 on the 21st but I'm leaning towards chocolate bar.

Jul 31, 2015

Hannah S.

It's a hard decision but I keep reading reviews that the nude is better so I'm stuckšŸ˜Ŗ @Robin M.

Jul 31, 2015

Isabel S.

Nude as in the UD naked palette? I would go with the naked! I'm returning my chocolate bar because I don't like it as much. it's just as pigmented but at the end of the day it creases and it doesn't blend well for me. maybe it's just user error, but I would go with the naked.

Jul 31, 2015

Hannah S.

Yes the urban decay naked palette sorry, I think I'm going to get the urban decay palette @Isabel

Jul 31, 2015

Gloria G.

I would also go w the chocolate bar pallette. The shadow themselves are waaay more buttery and easy to blend in. And you can do many looks with it

Jul 31, 2015

Jamie D.

Chocolate bar definitely. It has less fallout and more mate shades so it's easier to do a variety of looks. I use mine everyday, whereas I never reach for the Naked.

Jul 31, 2015

Nyssa R.

I personally love both, though if you want to stick with lighter shades I'd probably go with the chocolate bar!

Jul 31, 2015

Stephanie G.

I'd go with the naked. I hardly use my chocolate bar palettes. I'm not a fan of mattes.

Jul 31, 2015

Nicole A.

chocolate bar

Aug 1, 2015

Shelley W.

I have both and quite frankly...I love the chocolate palette more. I can pull more looks from that one than from the Nude. I actually gave that one to my daughter for her kit and I don't regret its absence at all.

Aug 3, 2015

Aurora S.

Naked. I prefer more shimmery stuff on a daily basis an more mattes for special occasions and photos.
In person, on a daily basis mattes tend to look too full for me.

The Naked palette has some darker shades but they don't look THAT dark and I just use it to like my lid for softer definition than gel liner.
The ONLY color I don't use is Gunmetal.
With the chocolate bar I don't even use about 5 colors

Aug 3, 2015

Makayla K.

Chocolate bar palette is what I always reach for. But I love both.

Aug 3, 2015

Maddie M.

Chocolate bar. Highly recommend. It has a mixture of mattes and shimmers, high range of colors and highly pigmented.
The naked pallet is way too shimmery. I don't like it at all. Great pigmentation, but not the best color selection, fallout, or variety.

Aug 3, 2015

Elizabeth J.

If you only do nude color looks than get the naked I love all three but if you like to do a variety or looks than get the chocolate bar my sister has it and she loves it all tho it looks like and actual chocolate bar so eat before you use it lol but if you like all three naked pallets go on www.costalscents.com and look at there reveled pallets 1&2 are exact copies of them and there only 20$ each I love them and they just came out with a third which has a lot of colors it kinda reminds me or the lorac pro pallet those are really nice so I say look into those.