Reviews

Sort By:
Log in or join now to add your own review.
Cassandra D.
Cassandra D.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Green
Skin
Fair-Medium; Oily, Normal
Hair
Blonde; Fine
I have this in every color!!

I love URBAN DECAY!
It is my favorite brand!
These eyeliners are the best eyeliners you will find!
They are beautiful colors and they are so smooth and do stay on for soooo long!
LOVE IT!

Alli Rose G.
Alli Rose G.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Green
Skin
Fair; Sensitive, Combination
Hair
Red; Fine, Oily
HORRIBLE!! Why the hype?

I tried to love Zero. It was the least pigmented black pencil I ever used. My Milani LiquifEye pencil in black was 10x more pigmented, creamy, and budge proof at half the price. I tried using Zero as a base and my eyeshadow started to melt off, not just crease! It didn't even draw color onto my waterline. Actually, non of them do. I tried this as a basic liner on my lower lash line and it faded throughout the day. I don't understand why these are so popular.

Alli Rose G.
Alli Rose G.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Green
Skin
Fair; Sensitive, Combination
Hair
Red; Fine, Oily
HORRIBLE!! Why the hype?

I tried to love Zero. It was the least pigmented black pencil I ever used. My Milani LiquifEye pencil in black was 10x more pigmented, creamy, and budge proof at half the price. I tried using Zero as a base and my eyeshadow started to melt off, not just crease! It didn't even draw color onto my waterline. Actually, non of them do. I tried this as a basic liner on my lower lash line and it faded throughout the day. I don't understand why these are so popular.

Julianne J.
Julianne J.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Green
Skin
Fair-Medium; Dry, Sensitive, Combination
Hair
Brown; Normal
Some of the best as far as pencil eye liners go!

I got a mini pencil of Zero in my Show Pony Shadow Box many years ago (the set is discontinued but its on the BL database). I thought it was such an awesome addition to an eye palette- I was a MU noob at the time- and I loved how the mini fit snugly into the package. I used it up and liked it, and I think its great to be able to use a sample up before getting the real deal. That way you can learn about new products but not feel obliged to use something you realize you're not so hot about. Zero is a nice black, it glides very smoothly, especially on the water line and the consistency is creamy. I have been wanting to try out all the other fabulous colors that have been launched year after year- but if the original Zero, way before Perversion, is any indication of how good these are now, I'm in good hands, or eyes! :P

Adriana R.
Adriana R.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Green
Skin
Fair-Medium; Oily, Combination
Hair
Brown; Normal
pretty good:)

I do like the creaminess and the fact that it is long lasting, however since it is so creamy and soft you have to constantly sharpen or use an extra brush and if you aren't used to having to do that, it is a bit of a drag.

Saw K.
Saw K.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Brown
Skin
Fair-Medium; Combination
Hair
Brown; Fine
Creamy and Stays Put

This glides on like a dream and does NOT budge. I had trouble getting it off even using Bifacil by Lancome which usually gets anything off.

I'm not an eyeliner user, but this may very well win me over. I got this pencil as a Sephora points bonus thingie and I'm glad I got to try one b/c I would not have purchased it, otherwise.

I would likely go for a brown, rather than black... but the black works nicely if you are putting on a smokey eye. Eyeshadow layers nicely over it as well.

Really glad I got a chance to try this product.

Chrissy S.
Chrissy S.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Brown
Skin
Fair; Combination
Hair
Brown; Fine, Oily
Creamy and pigmented!

Can easily smudge but it does work very well. It's extremely creamy and works well to use on your lashline to make your eyelashes appear fuller. I'm not sure what the difference between Perversion and Zero is, but I used to have Zero and I used the entire eyeliner up!

Laura D.
Laura D.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Brown
Skin
Fair-Medium; Oily
Hair
Brown; Normal

Best black eyeliner! I haven't bought it in a while because I was on the hunt for a better liner than this one but I'm sorry to the other brands including MUFE but Zero is still the best! Its rich in color and really stays on for hours and hours. I have yet to try Perversion but I'm definitely going to try it now knowing how good this liners are.

Melissa S.
Melissa S.
Visit Profile »
Skin
Sensitive, Combination
Hair
Dry, Normal
Pretty good staying power, flawless application

If you're into lining your inner rims this is perfect for you. It's stayin power is comparable to that of MUFE's Aqua Eyes, though it isn't smudge-proof in the same way because the formula is so creamy. This also helps with the application; it doesn't tug at the sensitive skin around your eyes like most waterproof stick liners. My only warning would be that it goes on very thick and dark, so if you're looking for something light natural-looking, this may not be what you want. It's great for smokey looks though! I love love it.

Denise H.
Denise H.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Brown
Skin
Medium; Normal
Hair
Black; Dry
I love this product!

Its all I ever use on my waterline and it stays on all day. It glides on easy and is the most intense black eyeliner that I have tried !!!!!!

1 2 3 4 .. 6 Next → Showing 1 - 10 of 52
Follow Us
Get the Beautylish Newsletter to hear about exclusive events, new products, expert tips and more!