Great for a First Gel Liner
I had never used a gel liner before, and let me just say that this was the perfect beginner product! When I bought this it came in a kit with a brush as well. The packaging is so cute. It's simple. It's easy to twist off the cap. You can tell which colors are which without having to turn the pot upside-down and look. The product itself has beautiful color payoff. I use the black almost regularly, and it is the most black eyeliner I have found. You know how sometimes black eyeliners look dark in the package, but they turn a little dusty/dull on your eye? Not this one. It creates deep, flawless lines. It's creamy enough to blend and create designs. It doesn't even flake off when I put a little too much on. The brush that came with this liner was really basic, so it gets the job done, but I feel that a thinner brush would do this liner more justice. This liner is so ridiculously waterproof. That is simultaneously a good thing and a bad thing... It's good because truly waterproof makeup is hard to come by. It's bad because it requires a little extra scrubbing to remove. My eyes aren't sensitive, but I know some people wouldn't be able to handle washing this off. Overall I am in love with this liner, but I'm always looking for a bigger and better one.
My new favorite liner!
Water Proof! I love it. Once I saw that I had to pick it up and boy does it live up to its standards. I have went swimming, taken showers and it stays until I remove it! I have it in black and I have not picked up my MAC Fluid line since I bought this.
Applies beautifully,doesn't stay.
I picked one up at Sephora and gave it a try. It has a VERY creamy texture,almost like liquid when first applied. However, it doesn't keep its promise on the 'waterproof' part. I find that it smudges very bad at the sides of my eyes (near the winged part) and under my lashline. I don't sweat much and don't have an oily skin type,so I know it's a problem with the liner. Other than smudging I had no other issues with the product.
this is really good eyeliner and applies super smoothly it is really water proof and stayed on during my shower, its also super black and doesnt let my skin show through at which is great. i love the brush that comes with it as well its applies really well.
A Love Affair Ended Too Soon!
This is great, when you first buy it... It applies like butter. It's very black. I could do perfect winged liner with it. It isn't waterproof though. It doesn't hold on my waterline at all. It washes off if you swatch it on your hand and run water over it. If you have watery eyes it'll smear. So I'd say this is not for someone with allergies! This costs me $22 and it dried out in less than 4 months!! There was still about a quarter of liner in the pot. I would try to apply it and it would flake. It wouldn't even mix with any liner serums properly. I feel like the price was too expensive for how fast it dried out and that it isn't truly waterproof.
I discovered this product from a swap on makeupalley.com and now this is my favorite eyeliner. I was not a fan of gel liners til I tried this one and now I have 4 shades. It's very easy to apply. It's smooth and pigmented and stays put all day. The bronze one has subtle glittery particles in it which I love. I haven't tried the black yet but it may also. The green and blackened plum are awesome as well. I hope to get more colors.
MAC who lol
I picked this up yesterday along with my naked basics pallet at ULTA, Ive been wanting to try it for quite some time now. My ONLY regret is waiting so long to get it. I am in love with this liner and the brush that comes with it. It stays on like a dream, it does not budge at all even in my water line, and I have super watery eyes. I only hope they come out with a broad color line like Inglot I would be in heaven(:
Really great eyeliner!
I thought this eyeliner was truly absolutely fabulous! It was a beautiful inky black, and the gel liner was lovely to work with. It had a good amount of time to smudge and move about before it sets, so you don't have to rush to work with it. However when it does set, it absolutely is not going anywhere. It sets wonderfully on the waterline without smudging or dropping down. However, it is a gel liner, and as all gel liners, they dry out. This liner in particular is better than the MAC fluidline in terms of durability, but as it is more expensive, it is only expected. My gel liner in particular lasted me about 3 months before I had to replace it, which is pretty great, but considering how much product was left in the jar, a great dupe would be the Maybelline gel liner for the same effect, durability, and for a lot cheaper. Although a great thing is of course the fact that a lot of the ingredients used are natural, which you can't get elsewhere. But overall, an absolutely fantastic liner to work with!