I discovered this product from a swap on makeupalley.com and now this is my favorite eyeliner. I was not a fan of gel liners til I tried this one and now I have 4 shades. It's very easy to apply. It's smooth and pigmented and stays put all day. The bronze one has subtle glittery particles in it which I love. I haven't tried the black yet but it may also. The green and blackened plum are awesome as well. I hope to get more colors.
I cannot express how much I LOVE this product!
...It goes on so smoothly, the consistency is just right, the color is bold and it truly is waterproof as it promises! I've used so many other gel/cream liners and this by far is the best! After one use and I realized it not only stayed on for over 12hrs but I had a day w/o one bit of smudging or flaky residue anywhere below my eyes...I literally went home and tossed out my other gel/cream liners! This is the best for sure...Definitely worth every penny.