Good: Super Prettyful packaging (it's kind of half of the reason i bough them). Very richly pigmented and moisturizing. Some of my other lipsticks dry out my lips but these don't. They also have a shinier finish than many lipsticks, and are probably the closest I'll ever get to wearing gloss. Bad: Comes off easily. If I'm going to spend $8 on a tube of Lipstick, I expect it to stay on a while, but this usually fades within an hour or so. Ugly: One of the shade I own (Russian Spy) makes it look like I've rubbed a vat purple goo on my lips. I guess it's just not my shade.