I used to breakout from using under-eye concealers, but this one works fantastically! It really lasts all day and so easy to use, no brushes needed. The consistency is really light and that surprised me for how well the coverage was. I suggest you go to a store and ask an associate to do a shade match. The great thing with Smashbox, the shade you use for one product is usually the same one you use for their other makeup products.