I had this liquid liner long time ago. It was recommend by a friend of mine. I decided to give it a try, cause hey, it's by Physicians Formula. But once I tried is on, it didn't come out so black and it was too liquidy. :/ I continued using it until it dried out or couldn't draw anymore. In the packaging, I believe it said in a couple of weeks by lashes would grow or something, but I didn't really notice a change throughout time. Whenever I'd have to use the liquid liner, I had to brush through the cap to release some product (kind of hard to explain what I did), but sometimes it still wouldn't work.
Best eyeliner I've tried! Better than Urban Decay 24hr liquid liner
For me I thought Urban Decay was too good because I really could get it to come off and when I did, it flaked-off and I didn't like how I had to try hard to remove it :P .. Anyways this one is amazing! I love the brush, it feels like I'm just drawing on my eyes, not flimsy at all! lasts long, great colour and I can remove it in 2 or 3 wipes :)
Love The Applicator
When I picked this up, they were out of the ultra black :( and the regular black looks more gray to me which I don't really like. I have to go over it a few times to get it dark enough. I'm also not a huge fan of the shiny finish. That being said, it goes on so easy and smooth. I love the brush tip. It works much better than felt tip liners, especially for winged liner. I have pretty thick lashes, but I think they do look a little fuller. It's really long lasting too. I'd buy this again, if I can find ultra black. ;)