This is the blackest eyeliner I have. I love using it as a base for my eyeshadows because it won't crease! It's great to have for a smoked out winged liner because the black is so intense. It's creamy, smooth, and easy to work with. Once it sets it isn't moving. I just wish it would stay in my waterline, but then again UD pencils don't even work for me.
Great for the price
Great value for a drug store product.. Very creamy but borderline too creamy if that makes sense haha.. The liner is very soft and does glide on nicely but the tip of the pencil is so soft that it flatens out quickly and the tip scrapes off on your lashes and leaves clumps of soft liner in your lash line.. The liner is very easy to line your water lines with but can cloud your eyes after applying it since it doesnt quite stay in place right away.. But intense pigment for such a low price
Beat Bobbi Brown
I wish I'd had my camera. About a week ago, my friend and I were at Kmart and I told her how much I love this eyeliner, she told me she already used Bobbi Brown but because it was so inexpensive and she wears eyeliner everyday, she'd try it. I went to her house yesterday and I asked her how it was working for her, and she brings me to her vanity, swatches the Milani liner and then the Bobbi Brown one and I swear, this one was a million times blacker and smoother. You have to try it, you will not be disappointed.
This is my go-to eyeliner. It goes on so easily and smoothly. With other liners it seems like I really have to work to get it to go on, but this one is effortless. For a $5 liner, hell for an eyeliner in general, I highly recommend it. I haven't found anything better yet. Did I mention it is insanely pigmented? None of this charcoal or dark gray crap, the black is very, very black.
OMG OMG! I was discouraged to try anything from this brand because i tried the cream foundation YEARS ago. At that time I had no knowledge of face primer(i had oily skin). I will never judge a brand based on one product again. This liner is the smoothest thing to GLIDE on my eye. It has the softness of a creme liner..but in pencil form! Amazing liner Milani!
I was using Revlon's Colorstay Liner for about two years and decided I wanted a change and have been eyeing this liner for quite some time so I caved and bought it and I will never go back! It is the most creamy and pigmented black pencil ever! I love it so much! The only bad thing about it is because it is so creamy you use a lot more of it than other liners, so it wont last as long. I have to sharpen it quite often but sooooo worth it!
Love. Completely reccommend it.
Out of, it seems, the zillions of eyeliners I have tried, I have not found one that I like more. It is super black and stays black all day (I've tried a few that seems to fade to a grey color throughout the day). I don't have to press hard to get any color, either. It is super smooth and perfect for the waterline. It also makes a good eyeshadow base for my duo-chromes because there is this like 15 second time limit where I can smudge it out real easily. After that 15 seconds, it's not going anywhere. I also have the gold and the brown. (I prefer black liner so, I rarely use the brown.) They are both just as phenomenal and pigmented. And the best part it this is a drug-store product so I don't have to travel to buy it or pay shipping because I need to get it offline.
What every girl looks for in pencil eyeliners
I'm impressed. Absolutely impressed. First of all, compared to Makeup Forever and Urban Decay pencil eyeliners, Milani's Liquif'eye liners are easily more black, pigmented, and glides on easier. However with all pencil eyeliners, there is a chance that this pencil will smudge, so I set the pencil with a black shadow anyway. Milani is also a drugstore brand so it will be cheaper than the Makeup Forever and Urban Decay eyeliners. Recommend all the way :)