Not for me - 3/10
I bought this product to try something different since my favourite kind was sold out. It said it does not smudge and its water proof. That most definitely is false, it smudges and comes off you're face with a couple hours.
Everything I tried with this did not work, it still came off. The price of this product is between $8-$10 at Wal-Mart, way to high in price for the results.
However, I have seen many positive reviews on this so I recommend you try it if it interests you, who knows, you could be one of those who have a good experience. I myself will not be purchasing this product again.
This gel liner litteraly stays on for hours.i love it because I have really oily eyelids and this alone doesn't get on my crease or smudge or fade.the color as well is nice it goes with any color eyeshadow.for the price it's a really good buy I don't have any concerns with this product I recommend this to any one a budget looking for a good gel liner.And it's also really really easy to apply.
Smooth and Creamy.
Great gel liner. Goes on smooth, dark, and stays where you put it. No transfer, smearing, etc. Very easy to apply. I have it in charcoal which isn't quite dark enough for me because I didn't check the color when I purchased it. It wears well in the waterline and comes in a nice compact glass jar with screw on lid. I have had mine for several months and they show no signs of drying out. I have several other brands of gel liner and this is my favourite. The only thing I didn't like was the brush that came with it, it did nothing so I used my own angle eye liner brush. :)
Pretty good gel liner
I got this awhile back, when I was hunting for an affordable creme/gel eye liner. I think I wanted the pure black shade, but somehow managed to get the charcoal one. I like the shimmer in this though, and it makes me think of Urban's Oil Slick liquid liner. The brush was actually pretty good, surprisingly. The handle was sturdy and easy to manage, and the brush had a nice stiffness and the silkiness of synthetic brush hair. I used this liner for a cute cat eye look. I used the edge of an old library/credit, etc. card to create a fine, straight edge, for the side of my wing. I thought it came out pretty well, and the brush worked really well too. This hasn't dried out on me yet- which is amazing given the fact all my other drugstore/elf creme liners have. The pigmentation is pretty good, but needs to be built up, and I think there is a tendency for the product to crumble up a little. I plan on playing around with this an eyeshadow base, and using different eye brushes with it. I love the packaging, and there is a good amount included in the little pot. So far, I have really liked Maybelline's Eye Studio products, except for a few problems, here and there. I do want to purchase more of these at some point, but I'm happy with Charcoal, for the most part.
I really enjoy this liner. The brush it comes with is not that bad either. However a flat liner brush does make it much easier to apply. I've had mine almost a year and it hasn't dried out yet. As long as you close it tight and don't leave it opened idly I think it will be fine.
Loving these Gel Liners
This maybelline Gel liner was actually my first ever gel liner of any kind..and I completely LOVE it .. since I began using this..I hardly ever use any other type of liner anymore..I still use liquid once in a while..and very rarely ever use a pencil liner..Im pretty faithfulnow to my newest love..Maybelling Gel liners.and the tiny liner brush that comes with the liner...wow its amazing too..Im definately in love with this set!!...normally in Charcoal but today I purchased a different color..its SAPPHIRE I havent used it yet..but its beautiful on the package,as was the charcoal,that why I made my first purchase..so Im hoping this one will be just as amazing!! This product will definately keep a home in my makeup cabinet .. permanately...definately a re-buy..
Affordable and fantastic
I actually love this gel liner. It's so cheap and it's so accessible. It's really pigmented and it lasts forever. For gym, I had swimming for four weeks, and I wore this, and none of it went around my eyes, and I didn't have to touch up my makeup like all of my friends (the color faded just a bit, I have it in charcoal, so it faded to a shimmery gunmetal type grey, I liked it though.) It's not as creamy as Bobbi Brown or MAC Fluidline, but it's still pretty fantastic, especially when you think about the price. The brush that comes with it isn't that great though - it hardens really fast, and you have to scrape off all the gel liner, wet the brush, AND THEN get the product on it. I'd recommend using a different eyeliner brush rather than the one that comes with the product. Love this eyeliner, use it daily. :)