Highly pigmented, great smudger, doesn't stay put.
I first decided to try this because I ran out of my Dior liner and I wanted to try something less expensive (Found it on ebay for 9$). I loved it - at first, because it's so highly pigmented you don't have to tug on your eyelids at all. But a few hours later, it had ended up way in the inner corners of my eyes and my tear ducts,and somehow on my lower lash line as well. Total bummer. I tried it a few more times with the exact same results. Definitely going back to Dior's pencil or even Estee Lauder's Softsmudge Artist's pencil.