Actually, this is the first time I’ve used ELF cosmetics. This eyeliner pen has a felt-tip that allows a good amount of control and is easy to use. And since it is waterproof, it doesn't smudge. It dries for only 3 days! It’s because I had it stored tip up. I’ve read from a blog that you have to stored it upside down so it won’t dry. I’ve wanted to give it a try again, and this time, i’ll surely let it stored upside down. :)
I bought this because I thought it was worth a try for only $1. The first day I used it I kind of liked it. Application was easy, the tip of the pen allowed for precise lines and I could control the thickness of the lines. However, after the first week the color wasn't as pigmented as it was the first day I used it. It came out like a washed down black color (kind of grey) and the pen was drying out. Well, for a dollar it's not really a huge disappointment, I guess. I should've expected it.
You get what you pay for.
I only paid $1 for this eyeliner pen, but I suppose you could say it was a dollar well spent? After purchase, I was able to use this pen for about a month before it dried out. I tried putting a little water on the tip to help it stay moist, but it didn't work. But I mean for $1, you get what you pay for.
I bought this with my first e.l.f haul back in July. I am quite disappointed in it! It arrived dried out and barely even showed up! The parts that did show up were an icky gray color; not very attractive at all!
The only reason I gave this 1 1/2 stars is because it is definitely waterproof. Took me forever to get the dang product off!
It does work
So this product cost $1, when I pay a buck I can not complain! If it works then awesome, if not, so what it would explain the price :) For the price I paid I am pleased with this product. This by far is not of brand name quality, but it does work. My pen clogged a little and you do have to apply some pressure. But I can't complain, if I have a dollar to spare I would rebuy just because :)
so worth my $1
You do get what you pay for,
it is not the best "waterproof felt tip liner" ever..
but it does work and for a dollar.. I think it is perfect!
I haven't had any problems with it and on me or the ones I have bought come out good. The color is dark and it stays on. I use this when I go to the beach or pool it doesn't smear on me and it does last quite a while.
It is super easy to apply and I would highly recommend to people who struggle with putting on eyeliner.
I buy this every time I see it at Target..
they tend to run out of this liner quick!
It's watery and "erases" on itself when I attempt to apply a second layer. I think I've bought it twice to give it a second go, and ended up chucking in the trash both times. For $1 I guess you can't blame e.l.f. but my $3 Essence eyeliner pen does the job just fine so I don't see what's up with e.l.f.'s. Sigh.