So I purchased 4 different colors: Copper, Plum, Coffee and Pearl. The Copper was not bad, mostly glitter, but good for the Summer and I'd use it again. The Coffee was almost black and I could not tell a difference between it and my standard black. The Plum was a great shade to start but went on sort of runny and did not dry. The Pearl could have been great but I think I received an old one since it was a little dried out and had the consistency of old nail polish. Overall, would I purchase these again, no, but for a dollar each it wasn't a great loss. I will continue to use the Copper and if the Stardust is ever not sold out, I might get that too.