Good for $3 bucks.

I really like this eyeliner but I always stray away from it. The color payoff is insane, the black is super intense! It stays on ALL DAY. No creases, no fading, no nothing. But the reason I dislike this product is because the eyeliner dries out after a good three weeks. Then once it's dried out, it begins to tuck on my lids when I'm using it. (Not acceptable!) I know it's only $3 but I don't want to have to worry about buying a new one all the time. That's the only reason I don't use this anymore.

LOVE LOVE LOVE!!! This is a great liner and it is so easy to apply. I have the black and the eggplant. The eggplant is Fabulous!! Beautiful on African American skin... :)

$ 3? No way!

Yes, this product works and is AMAZING! Try it and you'll fall in love! Creamy product that works wonders! I have the eggplant color because it goes well with my eye color (brown) and it looks great!

This liner is 3 dollars and it will be the best 3 dollars that you ever spend in your life! It is the darkest cream liner I have tried, it doesn't smudge or transfer.. It even works great on your waterline. I highly recommend purchasing this item. I've already repurchased once, and the liner doesn't dry out fast in the pot either. Another great product from Wet n Wild!

*THIS IS THE ONLY CREAM LINER U WILL EVER NEED*

this is the truly the best thing since sliced bread, lol! i was interested in trying it since YT guru "beatfacehoney" swore by it, and it is all that and then some! truly non-transferrable, water proof, smudge proof, budge proof! i put more use into my WnW than my Tarte, UD, smashbox, and Stila cream liners! its soo cheap everyone needs this!!

Amazing liner!

If you are looking for an affordable cake liner that won't budge, look no further! This stuff is simply amazing! It glides on easily and once it has dried, it won't budge until you remove it! I even like to use this in my waterline occasionally. I have higher end brands and this is definitely comparable, in fact, I like it better considering it is only around $4! The eggplant one is wonderful too! My only hope is that Wet N Wild plans on coming out with more of these!

I have been on a quest to find a new MUST HAVE gel eyeliner, so I picked this one up. It's everything these reviews say: creamy and true to black. I just don't think it's waterproof like it is advertised. It did transfer onto my brow bone area (common problem for hooded lids) but it is still manageable. I like it, but it's not my most favorite.

Amazing Product!

I'm actually torn between this and the Maybelline gel liner so don't make me choose!! I've reviewed both products and I must say that this product is just as amazing as Maybelline. It's super creamy and glides on effortlessly. At such a great price you would think you would be spending more but it's crazy cheap! I've only tried the black color and it goes on extremely black! No need to relayer because it's already very opaque. The only drawback is the packaging. It feels really cheap and I feel like the lid doesn't hold on tight enough. Though I haven't experienced it yet, I feel like the lid will make the liner dry up faster. Other than that, amazing liner!

The Best Eyeliner

This is the best cream liner I've ever tried. I took off half a star because it is kinda hard to take off! But I'd rather take the extra effort to take it off than pay more money to buy MAC's Fluidline. Whenever I go swimming or to the beach, it never budges & it is so creamy & easy to use. I do not like the brush it comes with though. It's a little to thick for my liking.

Best Drugstore Eyeliner EVER!

This stuff is AMAZING! First of all it is extremely pigmented and creamy, it glides onto your eyelids with ease and dries fast. It is waterproof, smudge proof and long lasting. Nothing lasts on my waterline except this! It comes with a small angled brush which works well too. And it's only $3.99, can't beat that price for this great product!