For 17$ I am soo happy with the palette. I love the colors for a natural look. The only problem with this I have is the consistancy of the eyehadow qualities; kitten is amazing, so buttery and soft and pigmented. Eve is a step down.. not so buttery but still good shadow and pretty color. Then americano is the worst. It is not soft and almost hard and hardly a unique color. It still creates a beautiful eye look with good brush.