Pretty good!

I bought this because I needed to spend a couple extra bucks to get free shipping, and this was the cheapest thing on Sephora's website. I bought the white one, and I don't really have any issues with it being too hard or anything, plus it lasts a long time. My only complaint would be that it's so tiny! I may or may not buy another white one sometime, but this is definitely a product I can live without.

Meh.

I got these in a makeup swap with someone, I was excited to get some colors I didn't really have any of, but they are so hard! I have to warm it up on the back of my hand, or deal with pressing on my waterline to get any color pay off.
I wouldn't purchase these!

Simple and great!

Ran into a Sephora very last-minute on the 4th of July looking for a bright blue liner to accompany my bright blue, sparkly eyeshadow. This mini pencil was five bucks and a great steal. It lasted all night. Will definitely be purchasing more colors.

Love it!

I got this liner in the sephora store a couple days ago. I just got the one in black to try it out and i love it. Its my new favorite liner. it goes on VERY smooth and its a very dark black. The first day i wore it i didnt set it with a black eyeshadow and it was still really long lasting. The next day i did because i was going to be wearing it longer so i wanted to make sure it stayed. I have no complaints about this pencil. Its very inexpensive only 5.00. Im def. going to be purchasing more of these soon.

I picked up two of these in blue jeans and silver green. The picture is silver green. It may be an old formula, but I found them rather lacking in pigmentation, bu they did glide on nicely.

Favorite true black eyeliner

It's creamy without being oily. I made the decision to stop tugging my eyelids when I turned 18 and this eyeliner is so smooth you can put it on neatly without any pull. It's not greasy at all , but has enough move if you want to smudge. It's also on sale 10 months out of the year and worth the buy !

I actually got this one in a set with other products, but it's become a favorite. It goes on smoothly, and has great pigmentation. It lasts a long time, even longer if I set it with a similar shade in shadow. I use it as a liner or for shading along the lash lines.

My friend got me a set of these for my birthday and they are great! I use them as an eyeliner and the are great as eye shadow bases under my UDPP. I also like lining a neutral eye with a pop of color on the liner. They do last long too but not so much on the waterline unfortunately.

I got this product on my birthday, when sephora does those beauty insider things. I absolutely love this eyeliner! Especially in the shade shown above! It really makes your eyes pop! It lasts all day too!

I didn't want to buy it... but now I like it.

I got it in purple. I was surprised to find it was a deep, pretty purple- not blue at all and not light like a lilac, (both look terrible on me). It applies easily but isn't toooo smooth...so on the plus side it doesn't smear... and is quite long lasting. To be honest, I usually don't really like the Sephora line but this was a winner.