I was actually very surprised by this product. It only cost me about 0.99 which was really good, but I also worried that it may not be very good quality because it was soooo cheap. But I used it and it honestly worked really well! It stayed on the whole day and was pretty easy to use. This had actually been my first liquid liner, and I had always wanted to try one but just never got around to buying one. So, I definitely think for this being my first one, it was very good. I would recommend trying this out!