back and forth...

I really wanted to like this, I thought it'd be a cheap dupe for my Stila pen. However, I bought it and it was kind of drying out (had to keep going over the line i made, which i hate doing haha) so I returned it to Walmart and bought another one. Same deal! Returned, gave it one more chance and bought it AGAIN lol. Used it for about 1 1/2 weeks and it was great. But then it dried out. :( I gave up haha maybe 've just got a bad walmart nearby

LOVE

I really like this eye liner. It makes using liquid eye liner much easier for me because of the pen tip style. It lasts on my eyes and doesn't wear off.

Fave Eyeliner

I love this eyeliner. You can do an easy fool proof cat eye in no time. It lasts all day and yet is easy to take off. Yes, as many as stated, it is not too dark as other eyeliners but you can easily build up to get a darker black.

Not a fan of it at all!

I wanted to try liquid eyeliner and I saw this at my local CVS. I tried it and I absolutely hated it. It kept smearing all over my eyelid. It took forever to dry and I had to keep taking it off. This was a total waste of money. It's not even dark enough. I wouldn't recommend this eyeliner to anyone unless they want to look like a raccoon.

Not dark enough

I tried this after seeing it on a video. She had the same color and hers glided on her eye so smooth and dark so I decided to try it. When I got it home though, the color was so light I could barely see it and I had to keep going over and over my line to barely see it. I wouldn't recommend this to anyone. I've seen some people on here get the dark color I saw on the youtube video and some people like me, who didn't get the pay off we were expecting. Hit and miss I guess.

dries far too quickly

This is alright stuff for the first 2 weeks. Then it becomes a shakeweight..you find yourself helplessly shaking and shaking it to get anything on your eyes. The felt tip pen is a great innovation that you can find in better brands like Stila's.

Not good

I bought it because it looked easy and it seemed it wouldn´t smear, but not at all, it doesn´t go on good on top of powder shadow it just goes uneven, and the color is not the blackest black it more gray.

This product was a waste of money for me. I could of just saved my $6 instead buying this. Usually I really like Revlon products. This pen swatches beautifully, but when you
apply to your eyes it goes on streaky and doesn't even dry quick enough. Blackest black doesn't even look black, its so watery it kind of blends in with your skin. The finish of this product is pretty shiny also...which I wasn't looking for.

It worked really well at first, but like within a week, it already dried out and the tip lost it's shape. When both of these factors kick in, the liner doesn't apply the same as apposed to the first time using it.

not for me

this product did not work for me at all. i was excited when i got it because i thought it would be easier for me to apply but i never thought about the quality of the product. every time i used it, it was never black enough; when i tried to go over lines it would just scrape off the previous line i did. it always smudged and faded on me. having used their regular liquid liner i thought it was going to be the same...but it wasnt. i will just stick to their color stay liquid liner