Love it

I am in love with them. I have 3 black , gold , and sliver. they go on so smooth and are very pigmented. I am so happy I gave them a try because they are now my must have eyeliner.

Amazing!

extremely cream and glides on amazingly! i literally get compliments everytime i wear this, and some of my friends who know about makeup ask me if its M.A.C haha! love it!

LIFE SAVER

OMG OMG! I was discouraged to try anything from this brand because i tried the cream foundation YEARS ago. At that time I had no knowledge of face primer(i had oily skin). I will never judge a brand based on one product again. This liner is the smoothest thing to GLIDE on my eye. It has the softness of a creme liner..but in pencil form! Amazing liner Milani!

Blackest Black~

I was using Revlon's Colorstay Liner for about two years and decided I wanted a change and have been eyeing this liner for quite some time so I caved and bought it and I will never go back! It is the most creamy and pigmented black pencil ever! I love it so much! The only bad thing about it is because it is so creamy you use a lot more of it than other liners, so it wont last as long. I have to sharpen it quite often but sooooo worth it!

Love. Completely reccommend it.

Out of, it seems, the zillions of eyeliners I have tried, I have not found one that I like more. It is super black and stays black all day (I've tried a few that seems to fade to a grey color throughout the day). I don't have to press hard to get any color, either. It is super smooth and perfect for the waterline. It also makes a good eyeshadow base for my duo-chromes because there is this like 15 second time limit where I can smudge it out real easily. After that 15 seconds, it's not going anywhere. I also have the gold and the brown. (I prefer black liner so, I rarely use the brown.) They are both just as phenomenal and pigmented. And the best part it this is a drug-store product so I don't have to travel to buy it or pay shipping because I need to get it offline.

I really love this eyeliner! I have the black one and it's, to me, a deep, very highly pigminted black and it's good for the waterline. I don't feel like I have to press real hard on my waterline or re-do it several times to get a good black line. It applies smooth, like butter. However, I do feel it does start to smudge rather quickly in the outer corners. Other than that it's truly not bad for it's cost which I think is around $6? Can't be beat for the quality it provides for a drugstore eyeliner!

What every girl looks for in pencil eyeliners

I'm impressed. Absolutely impressed. First of all, compared to Makeup Forever and Urban Decay pencil eyeliners, Milani's Liquif'eye liners are easily more black, pigmented, and glides on easier. However with all pencil eyeliners, there is a chance that this pencil will smudge, so I set the pencil with a black shadow anyway. Milani is also a drugstore brand so it will be cheaper than the Makeup Forever and Urban Decay eyeliners. Recommend all the way :)

Great color and texture

Aqua is a dream to apply: smooth and creamy! The color payoff is great too; like many others have said, I don't need to go over the line for the color to be vibrant. Also, once the liner sets, it stays! There's no creasing or smudging, especially when applied over a primer. Unfortunately, I find that Aqua stains my lids, so I'm not going to give it a full five stars. But I still really like it and will try the other colors as well.

I just purchased this product today, as I was watching a youtube video and was very intrigued by the guru so I decided to purchased it. I put it on as i was literally walking through my apartment door and I can say I instantly fell in love. It glides right on, it has a great color you can notice it immediately.

Amazing!

I was hesitating to purchase this eyeliner but since youtube gurus raved so much about this eyeliner I became more and more curious. So I was over at CVS one day and Milani liners was having the half off sale so I decided to get 2 liners and I'm so glad I did because this is the best eyeliner I'd tried yet. I gave one to my sister and she loves it. It glides on like butter and the staying power is super awesome. A must have! I will repurchase over and over!