This is by far the best "drugstore" liquid liner that I've ever tried. It's super dark and I don't have to go over it tons of times. It dries fairly quick too. The tip of the brush thing makes it really easy to control the thickness of your line. It also gives great control and is perfect for wings!
This eyeliner is awesome. It is very pigmented and so easy to use. I use it every day and it's the perfect addition to my eye makeup. Definitely recommend it :)
Works great for the price
I bought the darkest one they had.
It is easy to apply, gives a good amount of the liquid eyeliner, looks as dark as its suppose too, doesn't wear off to much through out your day (unless its a super hot day I don't need to reapply) under $10 at Wal-Mart.
Compared to other liquid eyeliners I've tried this one works the best (works better than MAC's version) I highly recommend it!!
Best Drugstore Liquid Liner!
I've been using this liquid liner for over a year now and I really love it. Since I don't have a steady hand, I usually stick with eye liner pencils or gel liners but this product is perfect for a klutz like me. It goes on really easily and smoothly to create the perfect wing. The only problem I have is that the waterproof version isn't waterproof enough for me, especially around the inner corners of my eye. It'll be fine for about 4 hours but after that it starts to migrate into my eye and burns so bad. When my eye starts burning like that, I have to take off my eye makeup, which sucks because I spend a lot of time of my makeup. I'll still use this product if I'm wearing it for a short period of time. This is definitely a drugstore dupe for the Lancome liquid liner pen.
Favorite go-to eyeliner!
I tried this eyeliner about a year ago and hated it because i thought it wasn't matte enough and in the sunlight it looked shimmery. Then I ran out of my other eyeliner and used this one for a back up and fell in love with it. Advice: Shake it before you use it, just to get the liquid on the applicator, I think that's why it was so dull for me the first time i used it. This is defiantly my favorite eyeliner <3
This is my favorite eyeliner. Though I've tried many others, I always come back to this. This liner can stay without primer on oily lids all day and never disappoint. Not to mention, the pen design makes it super easy to get a precise line in any shape you want. There's a ball inside that makes noise when you shake it (similar to a spray paint can) and it works well at letting you know when you're running out. Great stuff!
Edit: They are discontinuing this and my life is over.
HG Eyeliner for Crisp, Graphic Line
My favorite liquid liner. I have been using pen eyeliners from Sephora and Victoria's Secret and I've tried NYX studio liquid liners but every single time I come back to Maybelline's Line Stiletto. I am on my 3rd or 4th tube! I have combo-oily skin and my lids can get oily throughout the day, but this liquid liner somehow sticks through it, with or without eye primer.
By the end of the day, the most that comes off is at the outer corner because of laughing or crying when I might tear up a little. The finish is matte, and the application is very easy because the applicator is a really soft felt nib and not a brush, so I never have to worry about uneven product application and almost never have to relayer the eyeliner because it's so opaque, as opposed to NYX eyeliners which have comparable staying power but not so great opacity.
I would say that this is the best of both worlds between your typical brush-tip liquid liner and a felt pen eyeliner! My eyeliner is always very sharp and crisp, most likely because of the tapered nib of the applicator, so I recommend this as a great eyeliner for winged and double-winged cat eyes and as a strong accent to smoking eyes, but probably not great if you like smoldering eyeliners because it's hard if not impossible to blend it once it's dry, and it dries quickly.
The tube sounds like it has a little ball inside which is nice, since as you're running out of product all you have to do is shake the tube a little to run the product onto the nib. I wear this almost every day, and it lasts me about 6 months before I need another tube.
Definitely my favorite eye liner out there that I've used. The tip is fine and makes it easy to do any thickness you'd like. Also great for doing winged eye liner, which is my everyday look, so another plus for the tip. I recommend this product to everyone for sure.
I use this eyeliner everyday. In my opinion it is the best liquid eyeliner out there. You can use it for special occasions, everyday makeup, and even crazy makeup. I would recommend this product to everyone. Maybelline never let's me down.
The best liquid eye liner
The brush is not really a brush, it's more like a marker texture, but really fine, so that helps to achieve thin lines.
It's really great if we talk about precision, I have to do my make up in the car, so achieving great cat look like eye liner is complicated if my liner doesn't help, but this one is great with that.
I just love it!