Ugh! Smearing!

As well as going on and look, its awesome!....for about 15 minutes. this has smeard worse than any liner i have ever used. Its nasty looking and personally, i dont like looking like a raccoon. I wouldnt reccomend this to anyone.

I love the intensity of the color and the creaminess of the formula. It goes on well, but unfortunately makes you end up with major raccoon eyes at the end of a day (or night). The smearing is hard to wipe off as well. It's great for photos or touching up your liquid liner and that's about it.

smudges on me like crazy I look like a raccoon by the end of the day. Won't be buying this again, I'll stick to revlon's colorstay eyeliner thank you very much.

I wear this eyeliner often but i didnt rate it over average because it is too soft--i guess thats how to describe it. It smudges. Other then that, I like it. I love that it is easy to put on.

Great color payoff, goes on smooth, but it smudges wayy too much. And if you apply it on the top without setting it with a shadow it will be found also on the top of your lid. It's a great liner but not for everyday use unless you set it with a powder but then even sometimes it smudges, just not as much

Awesome Liner!

This was my FIRST eyeliner ever and I still love it till this day! It goes on very smooth. Gives you precise lines. The only problem is it smudges a lot and doesn't stay put. I try to set it with black eyeshadow but it still smudges through out the day. I would still recommend this if you are a starter.

Expected better wear from a liquid eyeliner

I hesitate to use this product because my eyes are quite sunken and I often end up with black lines in my crease when I use it. Granted I haven't tried it with a primer, but I feel like a good eyeliner should stay put even without help from one.

Great Price

This eyeliner is at a great price. I always use a base because it has a creamier formula. The color payoff is AMAZING. It is one of my favorite and darkest blacks!

Love it!

I absolutely love this eyeliner, it's the only one I can use daily. It is quick and easy to apply, and it doesn't smudge too bad. My absolutely favorite (:

Another awesome drugstore fine. I use this pencil liner on my lower tear line when I'm doing a full smoky or dark dramatic eye. It has a tendency to smear, but it wears well if you're rockin' a dark color on your lower lash line. Not the best pencil ever, but it's very soft and travels well. Definitely worth having in your tool box.