Best red lip liner in the whole wide world forever and ever amen. It's a little pricey but definitely worth it. I bought it back in 2009 and didn't use it for a whole 2 years (because I didn't wear red lipstick in that period of my life), and half the time it was even cap less, BUT IT DID NOT DRY OUT. I use it very frequently to this day and love it every time. It stays on super long too!
Over the year I have really fallen in love with wearing lipstick. With wearing lipstick you worry about it wearing off or feathering, so finding the right liner is key. I really like things that have all-day stay power & are low maintenance. These lipliners do that for me. It stays on all day I don't touch up once, even with eating a couple meals through out the day. It doesn't make my lips feel dry which is something I tend to have a problem with when wearing lipsticks. This is one product I'll continue to purchase.
I have a few of this liner pencils and they truly are waterproof for me. I can put it on in the early morning and it will not come off until I take it out with some oil based product. It is really fun to put a color like the 8c under a bright pink gloss for dimension. My other complaint is that the formula can be drying. I usually put a wax based lip balm underneath and moisturizing product on top. I wish they could make the product less drying without losing the color.