Both are GREAT!

I love them both great on all skin tones I think. Goes on smoothly good color payoff not to mention I love the smell and its for a good cause.

Great nude color for (almost) anyone

I like this one, I bought it when it first came out, wanting a pretty nude color for my lips but now I don't like the color on me anymore but I still use it on others and they love it (I prefer Creme d'Nude and Myth if I want a nude lip on myself).
I've always applied lipstick with a brush and I find that I can control how "nude" the lips get with the Gaga 2.
Overall a great lipstick but I probably wouldn't repurchase it for my personal collection, at least not for now.

love it!

I used this lipstick for my senior ball. One of my favorite lipsticks. The nude color is gorgeous and goes on smoothly, and I love the shade. I would highly recommend it. Very happy with my purchase

i tried it once

when it first came out and now....forever later! i want it and i cant find it any where!!! its the perfect nude lipstick!!! where o where can i get it?!?!?

love both shades, especially the first, pink one!

I own both shades (I bought them together in a set) and I love them both. I like the consistency of both a lot, although if your lips are chapped or cracked it can be obvious. I prefer the first gaga lipstick (the pink one) for my coloring and because it is more to my personal taste, but both are great. I like to do ultra feminine or almost barbie-doll looks with the pink one!

Absolutely love it! This Gaga lipstick is FAB. The warm light beige and the other very pinky! As soon as this lipstick was released I was out to buy it! I love Lady Gaga so of course I was going to love her Lipstick! Both colors are very beautiful and give a amplified finish. Very happy with them! Shame that they are only limited edition! I also think it's great that all money raised goes to the MAC AIDS fund which helps to support people living with HIV/AIDS. I was happy that I made some contribution towards that!

Kristen xo

Amazing

This is amazing. I absolutely love this! It goes wonderfully with my skin tone. Its sad that they are taking it off sale so thats why i got one of each and the lipglass.

Fantastic!

Its so smooth and creamy. I wish it had a bit more staying power. I also found that this lipstick was a bit more scented than other MAC lippies. (as in, it smelled strongly of vanilla instead of just slightly like vanilla.)
Still a fantastic nude, worth a try!

Got it

Love it like to mix it with some colors give it a ombre effect love this lipstick i give it 6 stars=)I recommend this product highly mac needs to make more of lady gaga and nicki manij lipsticks..

I am reviewing Viva Glam Gaga 2

This is my perfect nudy beige lipstick! I love how creamy and so pigmented it is and it does not dry out my lips. It has a good staying power too and it glides smoothly on my lips. Awesome!