I got this liner because my local Ulta was out of Maybelline's waterproof/smudgeproof cream liner pencil. I think that this is an ok liner. I say that it's ok because it's not waterproof, so it does not work well for the waterline. I also think the black could be a bit more pigmented. It works great for outlining a cat eye then filling it in with black shadow. I'm just not all that impressed with this product.
my fav. liner
this is my absolute favorite liner. it dosent tug on your eye, it gives a really smooth application and this is one of the ONLY liners that has lasting power in my water line. also i find myself putting black shadow over top of the liner to kinda seal in the color and make look really black, because this stuff dosen't fade like others do if you know what i mean-
I tried this and it was super hard. Hurt my eyes when I tried to line them. IF I was to say that it had ANY redeeming quality, it would be that it is good as a 'sketch-out' liner for when you are drawing out intricate face designs and you want something that is true pencil-like and not deposit much color so that you can then go over it with whatever you want.
I threw mine out after 2 months of trying to work with it. Just not worth it.