Good for Beginners

It's a felt tip eyeliner, It's shaped like a marker so it's really great for control. It does dry up a bit quickly! It isn't the blackest eyeliner but for $2 it isn't bad.

Actually, this is the first time I’ve used ELF cosmetics. This eyeliner pen has a felt-tip that allows a good amount of control and is easy to use. And since it is waterproof, it doesn't smudge. It dries for only 3 days! It’s because I had it stored tip up. I’ve read from a blog that you have to stored it upside down so it won’t dry. I’ve wanted to give it a try again, and this time, i’ll surely let it stored upside down. :)

http://princessmacarons.tumblr.com/...

Really Disappointed!

I bought this because I thought it was worth a try for only $1. The first day I used it I kind of liked it. Application was easy, the tip of the pen allowed for precise lines and I could control the thickness of the lines. However, after the first week the color wasn't as pigmented as it was the first day I used it. It came out like a washed down black color (kind of grey) and the pen was drying out. Well, for a dollar it's not really a huge disappointment, I guess. I should've expected it.

Good..But pulled my lids!

I was excited to try this out for a while now and so i decided to buy like 4 different colors. The biggest problem i had was that it was pulling on my eyelid harder than i wanted. I have the Jordanna Fabuliner and that does not pull or tug on my eye at all so i was shocked to see this product do it. After 2 months or so, I noticed the plum, midnight, and ash turned into black? it was weird because I couldn't tell the difference between these and my black one. I have pretty sensitive eyes so this product just did not work for me. Remember, what doesn't work with me, can work for you. You don't really know until you try it out for yourself so give it a shot. P.S. The price for this product went up $1!! Overall, I would recommend people to try it out for themselves but to be warned that they does dry up fast(hence pen), can tug or pull your eyes.

Good..But pulled my lids!

I was excited to try this out for a while now and so i decided to buy like 4 different colors. The biggest problem i had was that it was pulling on my eyelid harder than i wanted. I have the Jordanna Fabuliner and that does not pull or tug on my eye at all so i was shocked to see this product do it. After 2 months or so, I noticed the plum, midnight, and ash turned into black? it was weird because I couldn't tell the difference between these and my black one. I have pretty sensitive eyes so this product just did not work for me. Remember, what doesn't work with me, can work for you. You don't really know until you try it out for yourself so give it a shot. P.S. The price for this product went up $1!! Overall, I would recommend people to try it out for themselves but to be warned that they does dry up fast(hence pen), can tug or pull your eyes.

Makes life easier!

So when i bought this i was kinda scephtic..But when i tried it i fell in love. It makes doing cat eyes so easy! The lid can be kinda tricky somtimes cause it doesnt close all the way but for a dollar this is a wonderful product i will deffently be repurchasing :]

You get what you pay for.

I only paid $1 for this eyeliner pen, but I suppose you could say it was a dollar well spent? After purchase, I was able to use this pen for about a month before it dried out. I tried putting a little water on the tip to help it stay moist, but it didn't work. But I mean for $1, you get what you pay for.

Dried out!

I bought this with my first e.l.f haul back in July. I am quite disappointed in it! It arrived dried out and barely even showed up! The parts that did show up were an icky gray color; not very attractive at all!

The only reason I gave this 1 1/2 stars is because it is definitely waterproof. Took me forever to get the dang product off!

It does work

So this product cost $1, when I pay a buck I can not complain! If it works then awesome, if not, so what it would explain the price :) For the price I paid I am pleased with this product. This by far is not of brand name quality, but it does work. My pen clogged a little and you do have to apply some pressure. But I can't complain, if I have a dollar to spare I would rebuy just because :)

Ouch! This eyeliner actually hurts to use. You have to apply and apply to get even the tiniest amount of liner. It just looked awful. Horrible. Thank god it was only $1.