Dry to fast

Good product just drys wayyyy to fast
i like the intensity and precision but it doesnt last long enough i think i would be better if they did last long in a sense of drying and staying power

My love

I absolutely love this eyeliner, I use it to coat my regular eyeliner to seal it and bring out its bold color, it lasts all day for me and I never have to touch up! Absolutely impressed with such a cheap eyeliner! <3

Be Careful

I love this eyeliner BUT(it's just a small "but" though) you MUST be careful when applying that you use just the tip or you will smudge eyeliner ALL OVER your eyelid. Otherwise, great price, easy application.

I used it once or twice, and then it dried out and I couldn't use it anymore :(
I guess this is what I get buying a cheap eyeliner, but it was great the first day I used it. I loved how easy it was to apply because it's just like holding a pen, I wish it lasted longer though !

Unlucky me

Not sure if it was just my batch, but my eyeliner came empty. I shook it until my arm was sore, and nothing. Finally got a hold of one that did work, but it would dry too fast. It made application very hard if you were looking to use it for more detailed makeup.

My everyday eye liner :)

I've been looking for an everyday water proof eyeliner forever! since i love elf products, i decided to try this out! I love it so much i bought back ups! its only $1 and it dose not smug at all! So i don't look like i have a black eye :)

I loved this!!! If you worry it won't work for you go ahead and try because it's only a dollar and it's one of the best dollars I've spent.
The colors are very true to what you would expect. It doesn't give you the same look as a liquid liner (it's not so thick and wet like liquids look) it's very nice and doesn't smudge.

Remember to store with the lid down the that the color will stay in the tip and not sit on the bottom and dry.

Awesome product, Awesome price

The Good: Affordable ($1), Easy for beginners or liquid liner novices, waterproof, just an all around great liner

The Bad: Gives more of a "marker-y" type look vs the liquid-y look you get from a liquid liner, but this can be fixed by going over the line a couple times. The pic shows what I mean. The swatches are of plum, midnight, coffee and black.

Awesome product for the price

$1???!!!!! Seriously best product for $1 I have ever purchased. I bought the brown and black eyeliner pens and they are my go to eyeliners for everyday. They dont budge and are very pigmented.

Love these little things. My mom saw them and had to have one too. At first I only used them to line my upper lash line but my mom used them to fill in her eyebrows and now they serve a dual purpose for us. I have black, coffee, midnight, and plum. Honestly on me the midnight and plum look almost black.