There's good news and there's bad news. The bad news: It's pretty translucent and doesn't give you that true black look unless you go over it a few times. It sometimes smudges off easily... yipes. The good news: You can easily create foolproof perfectly-shaped or barely-there lines, and for a price so cheap; you can't go wrong. It's also easy to remove!
- Haley Y.
My Favorite Eyeliner Ever!!!
This eyeliner is the best one I have ever used!! It's super easy to apply, long lasting, highly pigmented, easy to wash off during makeup removal time, and it costs $1! Can't beat that!
It does what it's suppose to do but it doesn't stay on for long time. I had to reapply it a few times in the day. I was out of town and I somehow lost my eyeliner. I needed eyeliner so bad. I was a the Dollar Tree with my mom and I saw that this was only a dollar, so i automated amused that it wasn't good. But it actually okay.
- Brittany B.
It glides on super easy and its so cheap the only flaw is you have to go over it a few times to get the perfect black. I love this liquid eyeliner!
Wasn't surprised as I knew what to expect
When these were super popular I wasn't that interested. When I did a Dollar General haul awhile back and noticed they had a ton of ELF, including this, I figured the makeup gods wanted me to get it. As everyone has said you can't always get a fully pigmented line, the brush is a little flimsy/not precise (and for some frayed out a bit) but I am willing to deal as I already have a great liquid liner- Prestige liquid liner in black. I chose a brown shade in case I wanted a more subtle cat eye. And its actually great for that. When you want a cat eye, but not in black, it looks beautiful, and its great to just add definition to the lashline if you were doing a brown smokey eye. I recently lined my inner eye with Coffee and my outer/wing with a black liner to create a subtle, two-toned effect, although it didn't really register as anything other than a cat eye. So, while it is a little sub-par and not something I'll use all the time, I do believe a brown liquid liner is a must in any kit/collection. (And I needed a new one, since my other brown l.l. had expired).
I have grown to love this liquid liner not more than my Kiss pen liner though that is to die for. I have found out that I cannot wear this without having on eyeshadow this on a naked eye with just smudge off even though it says it doesnt smudge it does on me but hey I will repurchase if I cant get to my Kiss liner again. Its only a dollar who could beat that! I love liquid liner!
- Star Y.
Favorite Liquid Black Eyeliner
The black eyeliner is the only liquid eyeliner i use! I love the new tip because it's thinner. It might be flimsier than the previous one but i can make a thinner line. I would say it takes tie to use any kind of liquid eyeliner tip because everyone has a different one. I have tried other colors and i did not like them as much as the black. A few years back i bought a plum and ash one and it just had this RANCID smell about it so i had to throw it out. I did contact customer service and they took care of me and sent me a new one which didn't smell. It was strange. Overall, I love it and would recommend it to everyone who wants a fantastic eyeliner!
Not the best eyeliner
I bought this eyeliner at Target for $1 because I love e.l.f.'s eyeshadow palettes, but unfortunately the quality of this product let me down. Granted, it was only a dollar, but the consistency of the product was too wet, and it took a long time to dry. After it did dry, it smudged right away when I used an eyelash curler to curl my lashes, so I would have to reapply it. Also, it was a little bit of a challenge to apply, due to a stiff brush tip. My eyeliner came in the frustum-shaped tube, not the teardrop one pictured on the site sometimes, so I'm not sure if I got a defective/outdated product. Either way, I probably won't be buying again.
Hey, it's only a dollar. But I'd have to comment on the brush and the time it takes to dry. When I received the eyeliner, the tip of the brush wasn't as fine as I thought it would be. It was blunt and curved; pretty disappointed. However, the color of the liner is really black but the time it takes to dry takes a while. I have to fan my eyes for a good minute until I can do anything else.