I love these lipsticks! They are probably one of my favorite lipsticks. Something really weird happend for me. Classy used to be this light mauve pink color and recently i bought 3 different tubes and it was extremely dark and looked like seductive so i feel like it was mislabeled or something. These are cheap so it doesn't have the nicest packaging and it breaks really easy. It is creamy and sometimes the texture just doesn't feel right on my lips but once i get used to it, these are amazing. I love classy, nostalgic, and charming. Overall, I would recommend this product and try to get colors you will wear so you don't end up with a color you don't like.
Classy, fearless, nostalgic,flirtatious
Bad reviews are also going I'm just giving an honest opinion here flirtatious broke before it even arrived at my house and classy broke so the packaging is something they should work on...... As for the product itself all of them are Pretty well pigmented and they don't dry out my lips.....except for nostalgic I was so excited to get it and it's awful.. The product stays in my lip crevices and looks cakey even when ligtly applied... They are good for a dollar but I would rather spend 1.50$ on an awesome nyc lipstick. Classy is a dark blue toned lilacyish pink flirtatious isa nice popsicle pink,fearless is a fire engine red and nostalgic is supposed to be a light nudey pink but it's just a mess
I recently just bought two new ELF lipsticks, none of these colors, but the two that I bought were very pigmented! I was surprised because these lipsticks are only one dollar and are great!
Say WHAT only a dollar!!
Yes only a dollar for these lipsticks. These are really good lipsticks and are soo pigmented. These are very creamy almost to creamy because i have them melt before but for the price its not so back because you could just go get another one and not break the bank. I have tried almost all of the colors and my favorite one is captivating and flirtatious. I would say that the staying power is pretty good about a good hour or so and it doesnt dry out my lips to much!!
Drying and Barely Pigmented
I got this in two colors. Nostalgic and Gypsy. My mother got it in Captivating.
1. Nostalgic: It appeared a light beige color on the website, but is actually a pale pink. Nevertheless, I tried it out on my lips. Very disappointed right there. It was drying, not creamy, and if you rub your lips together it leaves a faded line in the middle.
2. Gypsy: Much better than Nostalgic. It's a darker color; somewhat burgundy. I won't say it's very creamy, but it's also not that drying. But it's definitely not moisturizing. Once again though, if you rub your lips together it leaves a faded line in the middle.
3. Captivating: This is the one my mom received. It was also a pale pink, contrary to the beige we saw on the website. It is actually a little bit worse than Nostalgic. It was VERY drying, definitely not creamy, and left a faded line. My mom's lips were slightly chapped before, but this just worsened them.
So, overall, the only one I would recommend from what WE bought would be Gypsy. But even then it's still not all that great. It's not hydrating as it claims to be and let's not forget that faded line!
Next time I buy e.l.f lipsticks I hope it'll be worth it to spend those two extra bucks to buy Lipstick from the Studio Line.
Cant beat the Price!!
These lipsticks are great alone and great when you play them up with liners/gloss. For $1 you cant find a better lipstick. Pigmentation is good and few touch ups are needed.
Value for Money or what?!?
This was the first product I ever bought from elf, I tried this lovely lipstick on and I was hooked! I got the lipstick shade: gypsy (Bold fushia) as I’d watched some YouTube videos on it and I’m sooo happy I did because its creamy (Moisturising), pigmented beyond belief, fab for a Bold lip, application is easy and fast, Value for money and the packaging does not break though the writing on my mine has faded Completely. The only disadvantage I have experienced is how long the lipstick stays on, it lasts me about 4/5 hours but if I’m eating food a bit less so you have to keep applying it but I still love this lipstick and I’ll continue to keep buying them.(i will upload a picture of the colour on my profile)
I love how this product does not make my lips dry out, and stays on for a long time before i have to apply it again. Beside that i love that the lipsticks are matte, and you can wear a lipgloss over it. Compared to the price, this product is amazing.