Eh...Average

I don't hate this product but i don't love it either. I used to love it but i don't as much anymore. It is good because it is creamy so you don't pull too hard on your eyes but because it is so creamy it smudges like crazy. I have sensitive watery eyes so i found that it would smudge in 10 minutes that i wore it and i have to set it with an eyeshadow which does help a bit. It's still not my favorite waterline eyeliner. Overall, I would say to skip this product if you can, invest in a higher price pencil eyeliner.

Disappointment

I actually purchased 2 of these liners, one in Ash and one in Coffee. Ash was the huge disappointment for me because by the time I got it in the mail, the pencil was completely dried out. I don't even know how it's possible for a new liner to just completely dry out, but it did. I even tried sharpening it (thinking that it might just be the outter layer) but still nothing.
The liner in the shade Coffee still works, but I don't really like the shade, it's a bit too light for a dark brown (which is what thought the shade was from the picture on ELF.com) it has a red tone to the colour which I don't like for my fair and Asian skin. Even though these are cheap products, I don't really recommend this. I think you will be able to find anyother cheap pencil liner at the drugstore that will give you better results.

Good, but not for long.

I like how the product looks when you first put it on. But that's it. Because later on it fades and smudges away really easily. Just like any other cheap eyeliner pencil I've ever tried. Plus, the cap doesn't stay on. I had to find another cap from a pencil I wasn't using and trade them off.

this is really a bad product...the black goes gray and doesnt last at all...the color is bad, the product is bad, i really have become very disappointed with ELF but the thing is the product is so cheap, and it definitely is a cheap product itself

Not good as an eyeliner!

As an eyeliner, I would NEVER buy this again. The black goes on gray, and smudges quickly - but I also have the brown in "coffee" which works GREAT for my brows. It looks fantastic and matches my brow perfectly. It also last a very decent time on my brows when set with a shadow.
Re-purchasing for my brows only. :)

Creamy! But Not long lasting.

I love how it's very creamy and easy to apply! The only problem is that it smudges a lot unless you set it with a black eye shadow. Even with that, it still smudges a lot. I wouldn't recommend this product if you have really oily eyes.

Not a great deal

It's hardly pigmented, a little rough when applying (could be smoother) and wears off right away. :(( The color when you pressed hard on your hand for a swatch is gorgeous, but everything else isn't great.