Benefit Cosmetics

They're Real Mascara

Reviews

Sort By:
Log in or join now to add your own review.
Giuliana P.
Giuliana P.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Brown
Skin
Fair-Medium; Combination
Hair
Brown; Fine
Looks great, wears okay

I like this product for a few reasons. It is easy to find in a variety of retailers, so if you're in a pinch it's not hard to find. It also does give a amount of volume with somewhat clump-free application. What I'm not too crazy about is the fact that it dries out super quickly, flakes, pulls at the lashes, and if my eyes water at all (if it's windy, or if I sneeze for example) it really irritates my eyes. Also, when it flakes and gets in my eyes it causes the same stinging reaction.

So it looks great but doesn't doesn't last super long , it's easy to find in many stores, but isn't a great price, and it dries out and irritates my eyes. So why do I still give it 3 stars? I do because it looks great at first and honestly I can't even say that about a lot of mascaras. I am a picky girl and I know what I want. For someone less picky than me, this could be great. It's worth a try, so grab a mini from Sephora (they're pretty cheap I think) and give it a whirl.

Olivia R.
Olivia R.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Brown
Skin
Fair-Medium; Combination
Hair
Brown; Oily
Dont like

I find this mascara dries out fast and I feel it doesn't do much for my lashes. I tired to mix with other mascaras I had, but I still found it didn't do anything. Not a big fan

Valeria F.
Valeria F.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Brown
Skin
Medium; Combination
Hair
Brown; Fine
definitely a buy again product!!

not to brag but, i was blessed by God and my parents with extreamly long lashes!! i know im lucky!! but one of the many struggles i go through with mascaras, because of my length, is that my lashes clump really easily!! i have very few favorites, and i only have to buy again mascaras, and they are the Mac's false lash mascara and benefit's theyre real! both have a great formula! but i kinda like this one better, love the wand with that tip for hard to reach places, and gives my lashes a sexy cat eyed look to them, great great great formula!!

Celia C.

Whenever I wear this, it looks like I am wearing false eyelashes. I only have a trial size from my birthday. The $23 price is the only thing keeping me from buying it. I have never spent a lot of money on mascara. One day soon for sure I'll buy a full size, until then I'll buy the $10 deluxe mini version.

Erin P.
Erin P.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Blue
Skin
Fair; Combination
Hair
Auburn; Normal
Gives Me Raccoon Eyes!

I love the way this mascara feels on my lashes, and it makes them look wonderful. However, part way through the day I find it around my eyes. Very unflattering, I don't recommend this product.

Esther S.
Esther S.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Brown
Skin
Fair-Medium; Dry
Hair
Brown; Fine
you can get a cheaper version

So i find this mascara just a good water proof mascara. I compared this one to Loreal Volumous Million Lashes in waterproof and I think it's better.

VML and They're real have the same waterproof formula if the VML is better. They both have silicone/plastic wands which I think works really well but brittle lashes because it deposits more. Which I like.
After curling my lashes and applying both VML and They're real, VML actually hold up the curls. and TR weigh down my lashes resulting back to ground zero.
In the end I would get VML waterproof over this one :)

Joy B.
Joy B.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Brown
Skin
Fair-Medium; Combination
Hair
Dry, Oily
I LOVE IT!

Omg, love it. Definite difference. I'm not a fake lash wearer so I love this! All around it made my lashes fuller and longer. Top fav of mine now for sure.

Sh A.
Sh A.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Brown
Skin
Medium; Combination
Hair
Brown; Dry
getting dry quickly

its gorgious and wonerful, but the thing is it get dry very fast, i only enjoyed it for one month, hopfully they will fix this matter at their next collection

Megan B.
Megan B.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Brown
Skin
Fair; Dry, Combination
Hair
Brown; Fine, Normal
Best Mascara Ever !!

I recently got this product and I'm in love with it. I really didn't understand what all the hype was about until I tried it and... Woah it has length, volume, it doesn't clump, it get every lash it does everything. I've actually had to hide it cause my sister keeps on stealing it. :P

Victoria A.
Victoria A.
Visit Profile »
Eyes
Green
Skin
Medium; Oily
Hair
Brown; Oily
It's alright...

I feel like it leaves my eyelashes clumpy :( and hard to take off! Apart from that its a good mascara and I would wear it every once in a while!

1 2 3 4 .. 16 Next → Showing 1 - 10 of 160
Follow Us
Get the Beautylish Newsletter to hear about exclusive events, new products, expert tips and more!