
Counter Confidential
"For the Love of Lips" by Undercover Beauty Agent
I’ve met some great people working at a counter. Some of them constantly come back, and I have developed friendships with a few of my clients. Others are more entertaining than anything else, though I do understand some of their idiosyncrasies. Little quirks about germs are understandable when it comes to dirty makeup.
Whether it be a lipstick, moisturizer, or eye shadow, testers can get filthy quickly. Bacteria and dust are everywhere, especially if the counter is near a door to the outside. Being sanitary is essential to any counter’s success. Providing new testers and cleaning used ones is something my counter takes very seriously. We try to be as hygienic as possible because contaminated makeup can transfer infections. There is alcohol, cotton swabs, tissues, lip wands, and mascara wands everywhere. Even if our counter runs out, we borrow cleaning supplies from another counter to ensure our testers are safe.
Recently, a customer came in looking for purple lipstick. When I showed her the hues we had in stock, she quickly became indecisive.
“Should I try a pink instead? I’m not sure if this is purple enough.”
She was conflicted and unable to choose a color. I gave her as much advice as I could, but ultimately trying on the lipstick would be the best way to decide on the shade. Unfortunately, she thought my suggestion was ludicrous.
“Absolutely not! Does it look like I want an oral infection? I watch Dr. Oz.”
She practically yelled at me (though she did apologize after). She had a deep fear of using the testers and believed that simply scraping off the top layer and sanitizing the lipstick wasn’t enough. Instead, she decided to purchase all the lipsticks she liked.
In total, she splurged on thirteen lipsticks that cost her around $200! I couldn’t believe it. When it turned out she didn’t even like all the lipsticks I asked if she wanted to return a few of the colors she didn’t favor. She replied “No, I’ll make them into gifts.” How’s that for irony?
*It’s perfectly fine to be afraid to use the testers, but don’t think that buying everything is your last resort. Trust your makeup artist. Usually we won’t let you use something we wouldn’t use ourselves.*

Undercover Beauty Agent is just an average makeup artist at your local beauty counter who's reporting true stories exclusively for Beautylish: "I love what I do because I get to make people feel beautiful on a daily basis. I'm a beauty advisor in New York City by day and a secret beauty agent by night, totally ready to share all my insider secrets and gossip."
More to Love
-
Counter Confidential: Lashing Out
- 29
- 15
-
Counter Confidential: Lash Application is More Dangerous Than You Think
- 467
- 15
-
Counter Confidential: Extra Crispy
- 60
- 9
-
Counter Confidential: Transformation at the Beauty Counter
- 48
- 14
-
Beauty Common Sense: Good Ideas and Bad Ideas
- 149
- 4
-
Counter Confidential
- 19
- 2
-
Counter Confidential: Unintentional Shoplifting
- 73
- 19
-
My Perfect Shade: Ethnic Skin Makeup
- 101
- 10

Undercover Beauty Agent is just an average makeup artist at your local beauty counter who's reporting true stories exclusively for Beautylish: "I love what I do because I get to make people feel beautiful on a daily basis. I'm a beauty advisor in New York City by day and a secret beauty agent by night, totally ready to share all my insider secrets and gossip."
Mar 05, 2012
Jasmine P.
Goodness, that's kind of crazy! I usually swatch on my hand to see if it will look good with my skin tone. Buying each one is kind of ridiculous.
Mar 04, 2012
Erica D.
I usually don't try the lipstick.But when I decide to do it, just scrapping the top layer is fine.
And funny enough, I don't usually let the make up artist see me scrapping it. I don't know why, I'm afraid I might offend them or something O.O'
Mar 04, 2012
Heather H.
I actually don't try most lipsticks before I buy them because I like bright or dark lipsticks, which are going to look bold anyway. The only lipsticks that I do try are nude lipsticks because it can be like matching foundation.
Mar 04, 2012
Amanda P.
at my counter we use a q-tip to scrape off the lipstick to allow the customer to try the color. and then we wipe off the entire product to make sure the layer is gone, and spray with alcohol. It's part of our job description to make sure things are completely sanitary! For me, sanitation is a big deal- if I don't feel comfortable using it, I'd never allow a customer to use it.
Mar 04, 2012
Courtney S.
Umm...so you people will put a germ-ridden lipstick on your hands but not on your mouth? If you don't think sanitation works, don't touch period.
Mar 04, 2012
Claudia C.
I never try them! Once I swatched two nude tints on my hand and ran home to swatch my own nude lipsticks next to it to compare..
Usually I will try to google as many swatch photo's/reviews as possible before a purchase.
Mar 04, 2012
Fatynn S.
just do swatch test on my hands, that's all. I would not dare to try any on my lips/eyes!
Mar 04, 2012
Ashley K.
I love these undercover articles keep them coming!
Mar 04, 2012
Kake A.
I wonder if she appreciated the irony and didn't care (or perhaps was gifting them to frenemies?) or if she was really that clueless (I'm trying to use my kindest words here). Le sigh.
Mar 04, 2012
Rikki P.
If I don't want to put it on my lips, I'll usually just test the lipstick on the tips of my fingers (thanks Wayne) to see how it'd probably look.